Unfolding Challenges of Business Model Innovation towards Circular Economy: The case of fashion industry

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference abstract in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Over the last decades there has been a call for finding solutions and implementing strategies that aim for more efficient use of natural resources and sustainable development within our societies (Brundtland et al. 1987). In addressing this, the concept of circular economy has recently gained extensive attention (EMF 2012; 2013), even though the concept is not a new and traces back several decades to Stahel & Reday’s (1976) work on the ecology behind product life extensions and their sketched vision for “an economy of loops” or “circular economy.“ Addressing circular economy is an emerging field in industry, academia and policy, however, there is limited research that studies this concept from a business model perspective supported with empirical evidence. Traditional fashion companies’ business models mainly focus on creating and capturing value from the sale of new products, while aspects related to circular economy principles, such as product take-back, reuse and recycling are often not an integral part. The aim of this article is to explore the organizational and supply chain related issues in relation to implementing a closed loop recycling-focused circular economy strategy in an existing business model. The paper is based on empirical findings from a 34 month long qualitative case study of a leading Scandinavian fashion brand and the study followed an engaged scholarship strategy (Van de Ven, 2007). The findings identify issues and challenges that impact the successful implementation of a product take-back system and closed loop recycling into an existing business model. The study shows that closed loop fashion is a complex matter with several uncertainties and difficulties that span across the entire value chain. Moving towards a circular textile system implies wider systemic change and innovation, not only in business models, but also in technologies, production practices, policies and consumer behaviour. At a micro level, the findings conclude that in order to integrate circular economy practices into the existing business model, rethinking existing value propositions and modifying several or all business model elements is required. For example, the findings reveal a need for organizational learning and a common understanding of the circular economy value proposition among internal stakeholders. An additional finding is that circular business models require an extended understanding of customers where it is important to see them as suppliers and co-producers of post-consumer value of products and materials. Finally, integrating circular economy strategies into business models may bring along radical changes to how companies perceive its products and relationships with customers and other stakeholders. Overall, the research provides a unique contribution as it synthesizes the theoretical and empirical insights from the field of business model innovation and circular economy with a focus on product and material circularity and management of post-consumer waste streams in a specific industry context.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationExploring a Changing View on Organizing Value Creation: Developing New Business Models : Contributions to the 2nd International Conference on New Business Models
EditorsRomana Rauter, Martina Zimek, Aisma Linda Kiesnere, Rupert J. Baumgartner
Number of pages2
Place of PublicationGraz
PublisherUniversity of Graz
Publication date2017
Pages26-27
Publication statusPublished - 2017
Event2nd International Conference on New Business Models. NBM 2017 - Hotel Das Weitzer, Graz, Austria
Duration: 21 Jun 201722 Jun 2017
Conference number: 2
https://new-business-models.uni-graz.at

Conference

Conference2nd International Conference on New Business Models. NBM 2017
Number2
LocationHotel Das Weitzer
CountryAustria
CityGraz
Period21/06/201722/06/2017
Internet address
SeriesInstitute of Systems Sciences, Innovation and Sustainability Reports
Volume8
ISSN2305-2511

Keywords

  • Circular economy
  • Business models
  • Closed loop
  • Fashion industry
  • Qualitative case study

Cite this

Hvass, K. K. (2017). Unfolding Challenges of Business Model Innovation towards Circular Economy: The case of fashion industry. In R. Rauter, M. Zimek, A. L. Kiesnere, & R. J. Baumgartner (Eds.), Exploring a Changing View on Organizing Value Creation: Developing New Business Models: Contributions to the 2nd International Conference on New Business Models (pp. 26-27). Graz: University of Graz. Institute of Systems Sciences, Innovation and Sustainability Reports, Vol.. 8
Hvass, Kerli Kant. / Unfolding Challenges of Business Model Innovation towards Circular Economy : The case of fashion industry. Exploring a Changing View on Organizing Value Creation: Developing New Business Models: Contributions to the 2nd International Conference on New Business Models. editor / Romana Rauter ; Martina Zimek ; Aisma Linda Kiesnere ; Rupert J. Baumgartner. Graz : University of Graz, 2017. pp. 26-27 (Institute of Systems Sciences, Innovation and Sustainability Reports, Vol. 8).
@inbook{4310e4c532da448e810b86c3898794eb,
title = "Unfolding Challenges of Business Model Innovation towards Circular Economy: The case of fashion industry",
abstract = "Over the last decades there has been a call for finding solutions and implementing strategies that aim for more efficient use of natural resources and sustainable development within our societies (Brundtland et al. 1987). In addressing this, the concept of circular economy has recently gained extensive attention (EMF 2012; 2013), even though the concept is not a new and traces back several decades to Stahel & Reday’s (1976) work on the ecology behind product life extensions and their sketched vision for “an economy of loops” or “circular economy.“ Addressing circular economy is an emerging field in industry, academia and policy, however, there is limited research that studies this concept from a business model perspective supported with empirical evidence. Traditional fashion companies’ business models mainly focus on creating and capturing value from the sale of new products, while aspects related to circular economy principles, such as product take-back, reuse and recycling are often not an integral part. The aim of this article is to explore the organizational and supply chain related issues in relation to implementing a closed loop recycling-focused circular economy strategy in an existing business model. The paper is based on empirical findings from a 34 month long qualitative case study of a leading Scandinavian fashion brand and the study followed an engaged scholarship strategy (Van de Ven, 2007). The findings identify issues and challenges that impact the successful implementation of a product take-back system and closed loop recycling into an existing business model. The study shows that closed loop fashion is a complex matter with several uncertainties and difficulties that span across the entire value chain. Moving towards a circular textile system implies wider systemic change and innovation, not only in business models, but also in technologies, production practices, policies and consumer behaviour. At a micro level, the findings conclude that in order to integrate circular economy practices into the existing business model, rethinking existing value propositions and modifying several or all business model elements is required. For example, the findings reveal a need for organizational learning and a common understanding of the circular economy value proposition among internal stakeholders. An additional finding is that circular business models require an extended understanding of customers where it is important to see them as suppliers and co-producers of post-consumer value of products and materials. Finally, integrating circular economy strategies into business models may bring along radical changes to how companies perceive its products and relationships with customers and other stakeholders. Overall, the research provides a unique contribution as it synthesizes the theoretical and empirical insights from the field of business model innovation and circular economy with a focus on product and material circularity and management of post-consumer waste streams in a specific industry context.",
keywords = "Circular economy, Business models, Closed loop, Fashion industry, Qualitative case study, Circular economy, Business models, Closed loop, Fashion industry, Qualitative case study",
author = "Hvass, {Kerli Kant}",
year = "2017",
language = "English",
series = "Institute of Systems Sciences, Innovation and Sustainability Reports",
publisher = "University of Graz",
pages = "26--27",
editor = "Romana Rauter and Martina Zimek and Kiesnere, {Aisma Linda} and Baumgartner, {Rupert J.}",
booktitle = "Exploring a Changing View on Organizing Value Creation: Developing New Business Models",
address = "Austria",

}

Hvass, KK 2017, Unfolding Challenges of Business Model Innovation towards Circular Economy: The case of fashion industry. in R Rauter, M Zimek, AL Kiesnere & RJ Baumgartner (eds), Exploring a Changing View on Organizing Value Creation: Developing New Business Models: Contributions to the 2nd International Conference on New Business Models. University of Graz, Graz, Institute of Systems Sciences, Innovation and Sustainability Reports, vol. 8, pp. 26-27, Graz, Austria, 21/06/2017.

Unfolding Challenges of Business Model Innovation towards Circular Economy : The case of fashion industry. / Hvass, Kerli Kant.

Exploring a Changing View on Organizing Value Creation: Developing New Business Models: Contributions to the 2nd International Conference on New Business Models. ed. / Romana Rauter; Martina Zimek; Aisma Linda Kiesnere; Rupert J. Baumgartner. Graz : University of Graz, 2017. p. 26-27 (Institute of Systems Sciences, Innovation and Sustainability Reports, Vol. 8).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference abstract in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

TY - ABST

T1 - Unfolding Challenges of Business Model Innovation towards Circular Economy

T2 - The case of fashion industry

AU - Hvass, Kerli Kant

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - Over the last decades there has been a call for finding solutions and implementing strategies that aim for more efficient use of natural resources and sustainable development within our societies (Brundtland et al. 1987). In addressing this, the concept of circular economy has recently gained extensive attention (EMF 2012; 2013), even though the concept is not a new and traces back several decades to Stahel & Reday’s (1976) work on the ecology behind product life extensions and their sketched vision for “an economy of loops” or “circular economy.“ Addressing circular economy is an emerging field in industry, academia and policy, however, there is limited research that studies this concept from a business model perspective supported with empirical evidence. Traditional fashion companies’ business models mainly focus on creating and capturing value from the sale of new products, while aspects related to circular economy principles, such as product take-back, reuse and recycling are often not an integral part. The aim of this article is to explore the organizational and supply chain related issues in relation to implementing a closed loop recycling-focused circular economy strategy in an existing business model. The paper is based on empirical findings from a 34 month long qualitative case study of a leading Scandinavian fashion brand and the study followed an engaged scholarship strategy (Van de Ven, 2007). The findings identify issues and challenges that impact the successful implementation of a product take-back system and closed loop recycling into an existing business model. The study shows that closed loop fashion is a complex matter with several uncertainties and difficulties that span across the entire value chain. Moving towards a circular textile system implies wider systemic change and innovation, not only in business models, but also in technologies, production practices, policies and consumer behaviour. At a micro level, the findings conclude that in order to integrate circular economy practices into the existing business model, rethinking existing value propositions and modifying several or all business model elements is required. For example, the findings reveal a need for organizational learning and a common understanding of the circular economy value proposition among internal stakeholders. An additional finding is that circular business models require an extended understanding of customers where it is important to see them as suppliers and co-producers of post-consumer value of products and materials. Finally, integrating circular economy strategies into business models may bring along radical changes to how companies perceive its products and relationships with customers and other stakeholders. Overall, the research provides a unique contribution as it synthesizes the theoretical and empirical insights from the field of business model innovation and circular economy with a focus on product and material circularity and management of post-consumer waste streams in a specific industry context.

AB - Over the last decades there has been a call for finding solutions and implementing strategies that aim for more efficient use of natural resources and sustainable development within our societies (Brundtland et al. 1987). In addressing this, the concept of circular economy has recently gained extensive attention (EMF 2012; 2013), even though the concept is not a new and traces back several decades to Stahel & Reday’s (1976) work on the ecology behind product life extensions and their sketched vision for “an economy of loops” or “circular economy.“ Addressing circular economy is an emerging field in industry, academia and policy, however, there is limited research that studies this concept from a business model perspective supported with empirical evidence. Traditional fashion companies’ business models mainly focus on creating and capturing value from the sale of new products, while aspects related to circular economy principles, such as product take-back, reuse and recycling are often not an integral part. The aim of this article is to explore the organizational and supply chain related issues in relation to implementing a closed loop recycling-focused circular economy strategy in an existing business model. The paper is based on empirical findings from a 34 month long qualitative case study of a leading Scandinavian fashion brand and the study followed an engaged scholarship strategy (Van de Ven, 2007). The findings identify issues and challenges that impact the successful implementation of a product take-back system and closed loop recycling into an existing business model. The study shows that closed loop fashion is a complex matter with several uncertainties and difficulties that span across the entire value chain. Moving towards a circular textile system implies wider systemic change and innovation, not only in business models, but also in technologies, production practices, policies and consumer behaviour. At a micro level, the findings conclude that in order to integrate circular economy practices into the existing business model, rethinking existing value propositions and modifying several or all business model elements is required. For example, the findings reveal a need for organizational learning and a common understanding of the circular economy value proposition among internal stakeholders. An additional finding is that circular business models require an extended understanding of customers where it is important to see them as suppliers and co-producers of post-consumer value of products and materials. Finally, integrating circular economy strategies into business models may bring along radical changes to how companies perceive its products and relationships with customers and other stakeholders. Overall, the research provides a unique contribution as it synthesizes the theoretical and empirical insights from the field of business model innovation and circular economy with a focus on product and material circularity and management of post-consumer waste streams in a specific industry context.

KW - Circular economy

KW - Business models

KW - Closed loop

KW - Fashion industry

KW - Qualitative case study

KW - Circular economy

KW - Business models

KW - Closed loop

KW - Fashion industry

KW - Qualitative case study

M3 - Conference abstract in proceedings

T3 - Institute of Systems Sciences, Innovation and Sustainability Reports

SP - 26

EP - 27

BT - Exploring a Changing View on Organizing Value Creation: Developing New Business Models

A2 - Rauter, Romana

A2 - Zimek, Martina

A2 - Kiesnere, Aisma Linda

A2 - Baumgartner, Rupert J.

PB - University of Graz

CY - Graz

ER -

Hvass KK. Unfolding Challenges of Business Model Innovation towards Circular Economy: The case of fashion industry. In Rauter R, Zimek M, Kiesnere AL, Baumgartner RJ, editors, Exploring a Changing View on Organizing Value Creation: Developing New Business Models: Contributions to the 2nd International Conference on New Business Models. Graz: University of Graz. 2017. p. 26-27. (Institute of Systems Sciences, Innovation and Sustainability Reports, Vol. 8).