The Maieutic Force of Mediating Instruments

Compromising in Capital Budgeting

Silvana Revellino, Jan Mouritsen

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This paper investigates how compromising plays a role when framing, developing and appraising capital budgeting projects. Motivated by Miller & O’Leary’s (1997, 2005a, 2005b, 2007) call for further research on capital budgeting to include not only valuation practices but also practices for managing and coordinating complex investments in inter-organizational spaces, the paper explores the role of the Chronoprogram in managing compromises and directing attention to concerns in relation to the development of an Italian piece of motorway(the Variante di Valico).The Chronoprogram acts as a mediating instrument which leads multiple and dispersed actors to compromising on the investment project. In these compromising spaces, which enable questioning to emerge, disagreements and controversies are temporarily appeased even in the absence of an interest alignment. The mediating properties of the Chronoprogram transform actions in unexpected directions which reconfigure the capital budgeting complex investment project and also extend the motorway object. The paper thus further develops the notion of mediating instruments by highlighting their maieutic ability to address the dialectics between matters of fact and matters of concern. It is in this maieutic capacity that endorses the dialectic between facts which give rise to concerns whiles the last offering possibilities to renovate facts that the work of mediation happens.
Original languageEnglish
Publication date2015
Number of pages47
Publication statusPublished - 2015
EventIPA Conference 2015: Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Accounting Conference - Stockholm Business School, Stockholm, Sweden
Duration: 8 Jul 201510 Jul 2015
Conference number: 30
http://www.ipa2015.com/

Conference

ConferenceIPA Conference 2015
Number30
LocationStockholm Business School
CountrySweden
CityStockholm
Period08/07/201510/07/2015
Internet address

Bibliographical note

CBS Library does not have access to the material

Keywords

  • Capital budgeting
  • Maieutic machine
  • Compromise
  • Actor Network Theory
  • Chronoprogram
  • Construction Industry

Cite this

Revellino, S., & Mouritsen, J. (2015). The Maieutic Force of Mediating Instruments: Compromising in Capital Budgeting . Paper presented at IPA Conference 2015, Stockholm, Sweden.
Revellino, Silvana ; Mouritsen, Jan. / The Maieutic Force of Mediating Instruments : Compromising in Capital Budgeting . Paper presented at IPA Conference 2015, Stockholm, Sweden.47 p.
@conference{4b7bcad9f93342a98b64690eb84b28ee,
title = "The Maieutic Force of Mediating Instruments: Compromising in Capital Budgeting",
abstract = "This paper investigates how compromising plays a role when framing, developing and appraising capital budgeting projects. Motivated by Miller & O’Leary’s (1997, 2005a, 2005b, 2007) call for further research on capital budgeting to include not only valuation practices but also practices for managing and coordinating complex investments in inter-organizational spaces, the paper explores the role of the Chronoprogram in managing compromises and directing attention to concerns in relation to the development of an Italian piece of motorway(the Variante di Valico).The Chronoprogram acts as a mediating instrument which leads multiple and dispersed actors to compromising on the investment project. In these compromising spaces, which enable questioning to emerge, disagreements and controversies are temporarily appeased even in the absence of an interest alignment. The mediating properties of the Chronoprogram transform actions in unexpected directions which reconfigure the capital budgeting complex investment project and also extend the motorway object. The paper thus further develops the notion of mediating instruments by highlighting their maieutic ability to address the dialectics between matters of fact and matters of concern. It is in this maieutic capacity that endorses the dialectic between facts which give rise to concerns whiles the last offering possibilities to renovate facts that the work of mediation happens.",
keywords = "Capital budgeting, Maieutic machine, Compromise, Actor Network Theory, Chronoprogram, Construction industry, Capital budgeting, Maieutic machine, Compromise, Actor Network Theory, Chronoprogram, Construction Industry",
author = "Silvana Revellino and Jan Mouritsen",
note = "CBS Library does not have access to the material; null ; Conference date: 08-07-2015 Through 10-07-2015",
year = "2015",
language = "English",
url = "http://www.ipa2015.com/",

}

Revellino, S & Mouritsen, J 2015, 'The Maieutic Force of Mediating Instruments: Compromising in Capital Budgeting ' Paper presented at, Stockholm, Sweden, 08/07/2015 - 10/07/2015, .

The Maieutic Force of Mediating Instruments : Compromising in Capital Budgeting . / Revellino, Silvana ; Mouritsen, Jan.

2015. Paper presented at IPA Conference 2015, Stockholm, Sweden.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

TY - CONF

T1 - The Maieutic Force of Mediating Instruments

T2 - Compromising in Capital Budgeting

AU - Revellino, Silvana

AU - Mouritsen, Jan

N1 - CBS Library does not have access to the material

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - This paper investigates how compromising plays a role when framing, developing and appraising capital budgeting projects. Motivated by Miller & O’Leary’s (1997, 2005a, 2005b, 2007) call for further research on capital budgeting to include not only valuation practices but also practices for managing and coordinating complex investments in inter-organizational spaces, the paper explores the role of the Chronoprogram in managing compromises and directing attention to concerns in relation to the development of an Italian piece of motorway(the Variante di Valico).The Chronoprogram acts as a mediating instrument which leads multiple and dispersed actors to compromising on the investment project. In these compromising spaces, which enable questioning to emerge, disagreements and controversies are temporarily appeased even in the absence of an interest alignment. The mediating properties of the Chronoprogram transform actions in unexpected directions which reconfigure the capital budgeting complex investment project and also extend the motorway object. The paper thus further develops the notion of mediating instruments by highlighting their maieutic ability to address the dialectics between matters of fact and matters of concern. It is in this maieutic capacity that endorses the dialectic between facts which give rise to concerns whiles the last offering possibilities to renovate facts that the work of mediation happens.

AB - This paper investigates how compromising plays a role when framing, developing and appraising capital budgeting projects. Motivated by Miller & O’Leary’s (1997, 2005a, 2005b, 2007) call for further research on capital budgeting to include not only valuation practices but also practices for managing and coordinating complex investments in inter-organizational spaces, the paper explores the role of the Chronoprogram in managing compromises and directing attention to concerns in relation to the development of an Italian piece of motorway(the Variante di Valico).The Chronoprogram acts as a mediating instrument which leads multiple and dispersed actors to compromising on the investment project. In these compromising spaces, which enable questioning to emerge, disagreements and controversies are temporarily appeased even in the absence of an interest alignment. The mediating properties of the Chronoprogram transform actions in unexpected directions which reconfigure the capital budgeting complex investment project and also extend the motorway object. The paper thus further develops the notion of mediating instruments by highlighting their maieutic ability to address the dialectics between matters of fact and matters of concern. It is in this maieutic capacity that endorses the dialectic between facts which give rise to concerns whiles the last offering possibilities to renovate facts that the work of mediation happens.

KW - Capital budgeting

KW - Maieutic machine

KW - Compromise

KW - Actor Network Theory

KW - Chronoprogram

KW - Construction industry

KW - Capital budgeting

KW - Maieutic machine

KW - Compromise

KW - Actor Network Theory

KW - Chronoprogram

KW - Construction Industry

M3 - Paper

ER -

Revellino S, Mouritsen J. The Maieutic Force of Mediating Instruments: Compromising in Capital Budgeting . 2015. Paper presented at IPA Conference 2015, Stockholm, Sweden.