The Beauty and the Abuse

A Workshop for Dialogue, Reflexivity, and Action

Ana Maria Munar, Kellee Caton, Claudia Eger, Heather Jeffrey, Catheryn Khoo-Lattimore, Nigel Morgan, Elaine Yang

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference abstract in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    This workshop presents a handbook and a method to enhance dialogue, reflexivity, and action on the beauty and the abuse which characterizes human relationships and emotions in academic environments. Academic lives are often characterized by a blurring of boundaries between personal and professional spheres. The main aim of this workshop is to help create spaces of trust, where academics can reflect on experiences and complex issues, which are often considered taboo, shameful, or private, although these experiences have a major impact on our wellbeing and working lives. A series of vignettes inspired in real stories are presented. These stories all have in common that they deal with the lights and the shadows of how eroticism, love, sex, power, prejudice, and gendered academic identities and cultures shape our working environments and influence our career choices and trajectories. Each vignette section deals with one or several of the following themes: friendship love, romantic love, flirting, eroticism, sex, desire, dating cultures, committed relationships, paternalistic sexism, hostile sexism, sexual harassment, and jealousy. The vignettes have been anonymized but provide veridical accounts of stories and experiences in academia. Each story consists of the vignette’s narrative and the presentation of a personal dilemma for discussion. The handbook includes a thematic list of resources for inspiration and further action, which includes recommended readings, literature, and online materials, such as guidelines and policies, links to online forums, associations, and initiatives that can provide support. Workshop Method After a brief introduction, the participants will be divided into groups. The group activities (describing, reflecting, and sharing) will be facilitated by the authors: Describing: The vignette narrative is read out loud. Reflecting: The dilemma is presented, and participants are asked to write down their own feelings and thoughts related to the vignette narrative and to consider aspects such as these: Embodiment and feeling. How did they feel when listening to this story? Where did the emotion feel in their bodies? Identification and empathy. How do they think they would have felt or acted in relation to the narrative (1) if they were the protagonist of the story and (2) if they were a colleague who was a witness to the story?
    Sharing: The facilitator moderates the dialogue and asks each of the participants to share what they have written and their thoughts and opinions. The activity ends with pointing out the available resources and asking participants to share their knowledge about other resources they may know about which may benefit the group.
    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publication2017 Critical Tourism Studies Proceedings. CTS 7
    EditorsKellee Caton
    Number of pages1
    Place of PublicationKamloops, BC
    PublisherThompson Rivers University
    Publication date2017
    Article number46
    ISBN (Electronic)9780991687121
    Publication statusPublished - 2017
    Event7th Critical Tourism Studies Conference 2017 - Palma de Mallorca, Spain
    Duration: 25 Jun 201729 Jun 2017
    Conference number: 7
    https://www.criticaltourismstudies.info/

    Conference

    Conference7th Critical Tourism Studies Conference 2017
    Number7
    CountrySpain
    CityPalma de Mallorca
    Period25/06/201729/06/2017
    Internet address

    Cite this

    Munar, A. M., Caton, K., Eger, C., Jeffrey, H., Khoo-Lattimore, C., Morgan, N., & Yang, E. (2017). The Beauty and the Abuse: A Workshop for Dialogue, Reflexivity, and Action. In K. Caton (Ed.), 2017 Critical Tourism Studies Proceedings. CTS 7 [46] Kamloops, BC: Thompson Rivers University.
    Munar, Ana Maria ; Caton, Kellee ; Eger, Claudia ; Jeffrey, Heather ; Khoo-Lattimore, Catheryn ; Morgan, Nigel ; Yang, Elaine. / The Beauty and the Abuse : A Workshop for Dialogue, Reflexivity, and Action. 2017 Critical Tourism Studies Proceedings. CTS 7. editor / Kellee Caton. Kamloops, BC : Thompson Rivers University, 2017.
    @inbook{0c87f1dbc65d45d08357361141786288,
    title = "The Beauty and the Abuse: A Workshop for Dialogue, Reflexivity, and Action",
    abstract = "This workshop presents a handbook and a method to enhance dialogue, reflexivity, and action on the beauty and the abuse which characterizes human relationships and emotions in academic environments. Academic lives are often characterized by a blurring of boundaries between personal and professional spheres. The main aim of this workshop is to help create spaces of trust, where academics can reflect on experiences and complex issues, which are often considered taboo, shameful, or private, although these experiences have a major impact on our wellbeing and working lives. A series of vignettes inspired in real stories are presented. These stories all have in common that they deal with the lights and the shadows of how eroticism, love, sex, power, prejudice, and gendered academic identities and cultures shape our working environments and influence our career choices and trajectories. Each vignette section deals with one or several of the following themes: friendship love, romantic love, flirting, eroticism, sex, desire, dating cultures, committed relationships, paternalistic sexism, hostile sexism, sexual harassment, and jealousy. The vignettes have been anonymized but provide veridical accounts of stories and experiences in academia. Each story consists of the vignette’s narrative and the presentation of a personal dilemma for discussion. The handbook includes a thematic list of resources for inspiration and further action, which includes recommended readings, literature, and online materials, such as guidelines and policies, links to online forums, associations, and initiatives that can provide support. Workshop Method After a brief introduction, the participants will be divided into groups. The group activities (describing, reflecting, and sharing) will be facilitated by the authors: Describing: The vignette narrative is read out loud. Reflecting: The dilemma is presented, and participants are asked to write down their own feelings and thoughts related to the vignette narrative and to consider aspects such as these: Embodiment and feeling. How did they feel when listening to this story? Where did the emotion feel in their bodies? Identification and empathy. How do they think they would have felt or acted in relation to the narrative (1) if they were the protagonist of the story and (2) if they were a colleague who was a witness to the story?Sharing: The facilitator moderates the dialogue and asks each of the participants to share what they have written and their thoughts and opinions. The activity ends with pointing out the available resources and asking participants to share their knowledge about other resources they may know about which may benefit the group.",
    author = "Munar, {Ana Maria} and Kellee Caton and Claudia Eger and Heather Jeffrey and Catheryn Khoo-Lattimore and Nigel Morgan and Elaine Yang",
    year = "2017",
    language = "English",
    editor = "Kellee Caton",
    booktitle = "2017 Critical Tourism Studies Proceedings. CTS 7",
    publisher = "Thompson Rivers University",

    }

    Munar, AM, Caton, K, Eger, C, Jeffrey, H, Khoo-Lattimore, C, Morgan, N & Yang, E 2017, The Beauty and the Abuse: A Workshop for Dialogue, Reflexivity, and Action. in K Caton (ed.), 2017 Critical Tourism Studies Proceedings. CTS 7., 46, Thompson Rivers University, Kamloops, BC, Palma de Mallorca, Spain, 25/06/2017.

    The Beauty and the Abuse : A Workshop for Dialogue, Reflexivity, and Action. / Munar, Ana Maria; Caton, Kellee; Eger, Claudia; Jeffrey, Heather; Khoo-Lattimore, Catheryn; Morgan, Nigel; Yang, Elaine.

    2017 Critical Tourism Studies Proceedings. CTS 7. ed. / Kellee Caton. Kamloops, BC : Thompson Rivers University, 2017. 46.

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference abstract in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

    TY - ABST

    T1 - The Beauty and the Abuse

    T2 - A Workshop for Dialogue, Reflexivity, and Action

    AU - Munar, Ana Maria

    AU - Caton, Kellee

    AU - Eger, Claudia

    AU - Jeffrey, Heather

    AU - Khoo-Lattimore, Catheryn

    AU - Morgan, Nigel

    AU - Yang, Elaine

    PY - 2017

    Y1 - 2017

    N2 - This workshop presents a handbook and a method to enhance dialogue, reflexivity, and action on the beauty and the abuse which characterizes human relationships and emotions in academic environments. Academic lives are often characterized by a blurring of boundaries between personal and professional spheres. The main aim of this workshop is to help create spaces of trust, where academics can reflect on experiences and complex issues, which are often considered taboo, shameful, or private, although these experiences have a major impact on our wellbeing and working lives. A series of vignettes inspired in real stories are presented. These stories all have in common that they deal with the lights and the shadows of how eroticism, love, sex, power, prejudice, and gendered academic identities and cultures shape our working environments and influence our career choices and trajectories. Each vignette section deals with one or several of the following themes: friendship love, romantic love, flirting, eroticism, sex, desire, dating cultures, committed relationships, paternalistic sexism, hostile sexism, sexual harassment, and jealousy. The vignettes have been anonymized but provide veridical accounts of stories and experiences in academia. Each story consists of the vignette’s narrative and the presentation of a personal dilemma for discussion. The handbook includes a thematic list of resources for inspiration and further action, which includes recommended readings, literature, and online materials, such as guidelines and policies, links to online forums, associations, and initiatives that can provide support. Workshop Method After a brief introduction, the participants will be divided into groups. The group activities (describing, reflecting, and sharing) will be facilitated by the authors: Describing: The vignette narrative is read out loud. Reflecting: The dilemma is presented, and participants are asked to write down their own feelings and thoughts related to the vignette narrative and to consider aspects such as these: Embodiment and feeling. How did they feel when listening to this story? Where did the emotion feel in their bodies? Identification and empathy. How do they think they would have felt or acted in relation to the narrative (1) if they were the protagonist of the story and (2) if they were a colleague who was a witness to the story?Sharing: The facilitator moderates the dialogue and asks each of the participants to share what they have written and their thoughts and opinions. The activity ends with pointing out the available resources and asking participants to share their knowledge about other resources they may know about which may benefit the group.

    AB - This workshop presents a handbook and a method to enhance dialogue, reflexivity, and action on the beauty and the abuse which characterizes human relationships and emotions in academic environments. Academic lives are often characterized by a blurring of boundaries between personal and professional spheres. The main aim of this workshop is to help create spaces of trust, where academics can reflect on experiences and complex issues, which are often considered taboo, shameful, or private, although these experiences have a major impact on our wellbeing and working lives. A series of vignettes inspired in real stories are presented. These stories all have in common that they deal with the lights and the shadows of how eroticism, love, sex, power, prejudice, and gendered academic identities and cultures shape our working environments and influence our career choices and trajectories. Each vignette section deals with one or several of the following themes: friendship love, romantic love, flirting, eroticism, sex, desire, dating cultures, committed relationships, paternalistic sexism, hostile sexism, sexual harassment, and jealousy. The vignettes have been anonymized but provide veridical accounts of stories and experiences in academia. Each story consists of the vignette’s narrative and the presentation of a personal dilemma for discussion. The handbook includes a thematic list of resources for inspiration and further action, which includes recommended readings, literature, and online materials, such as guidelines and policies, links to online forums, associations, and initiatives that can provide support. Workshop Method After a brief introduction, the participants will be divided into groups. The group activities (describing, reflecting, and sharing) will be facilitated by the authors: Describing: The vignette narrative is read out loud. Reflecting: The dilemma is presented, and participants are asked to write down their own feelings and thoughts related to the vignette narrative and to consider aspects such as these: Embodiment and feeling. How did they feel when listening to this story? Where did the emotion feel in their bodies? Identification and empathy. How do they think they would have felt or acted in relation to the narrative (1) if they were the protagonist of the story and (2) if they were a colleague who was a witness to the story?Sharing: The facilitator moderates the dialogue and asks each of the participants to share what they have written and their thoughts and opinions. The activity ends with pointing out the available resources and asking participants to share their knowledge about other resources they may know about which may benefit the group.

    M3 - Conference abstract in proceedings

    BT - 2017 Critical Tourism Studies Proceedings. CTS 7

    A2 - Caton, Kellee

    PB - Thompson Rivers University

    CY - Kamloops, BC

    ER -

    Munar AM, Caton K, Eger C, Jeffrey H, Khoo-Lattimore C, Morgan N et al. The Beauty and the Abuse: A Workshop for Dialogue, Reflexivity, and Action. In Caton K, editor, 2017 Critical Tourism Studies Proceedings. CTS 7. Kamloops, BC: Thompson Rivers University. 2017. 46