State of the Art: Overview of Concepts, Indicators and Methodologies Used for Analyzing the Social OMCs

Research output: Working paperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This paper is a detailed analysis about the literature on the Social OMC from 2006-2010, focusing on how OMC research has been carried out. It specifically points to which theoretical framework/concepts are used, and how change is conceptualised and measured. It is organised in five sections. The first concerns visibility and awareness about the OMC; the second analyses research on the EU level coordination process; the third scrutinizes how features of the OMC have been analysed. The fourth and fifth sections, addressing how national integration of the OMC has been researched, respectively address substantive policy change as well as national policy-making. Strikingly, virtually all OMC research adopts theoretical frameworks derived from literature on Europeanisation and/or institutionalisation. Also, as the OMC is voluntary and sanction-free, it depends heavily on how and the the extent to which actors use it (agenda-setting, conflict resolution, maintaining focus on a policy issue, developing a policy dialogue, etc). OMC research has become nuanced and does highlight how, for which purpose and with which outcome actors engage with the OMC. Another finding is that there is data on policy issues addressed through the OMC, learning does take place and there is knowledge about domestic policy problems. However, the linkage between knowledge of an issue and direct use of the OMC for policy change in social policy is weak, but that may change with EU2020, where social policy has received a higher profile. Most research covers the EU-15, much more research needs to be undertaken in newer EU member states.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationEdinburgh
PublisherThe University of Edinburgh
Number of pages53
Publication statusPublished - 2010
Externally publishedYes
SeriesWorking Papers on the Reconciliation of Work and Welfare in Europe
NumberREC-WP 15/10

Keywords

  • OMC
  • Social inclusion
  • Pensions
  • Health care and care for the elderly
  • Theoretical approach
  • Methods
  • Indicators
  • Measurement

Cite this

de la Porte, C. (2010). State of the Art: Overview of Concepts, Indicators and Methodologies Used for Analyzing the Social OMCs. Edinburgh: The University of Edinburgh. Working Papers on the Reconciliation of Work and Welfare in Europe, No. REC-WP 15/10
de la Porte, Caroline. / State of the Art : Overview of Concepts, Indicators and Methodologies Used for Analyzing the Social OMCs. Edinburgh : The University of Edinburgh, 2010. (Working Papers on the Reconciliation of Work and Welfare in Europe; No. REC-WP 15/10).
@techreport{8671a112e2eb40bb819ae4855e32a823,
title = "State of the Art: Overview of Concepts, Indicators and Methodologies Used for Analyzing the Social OMCs",
abstract = "This paper is a detailed analysis about the literature on the Social OMC from 2006-2010, focusing on how OMC research has been carried out. It specifically points to which theoretical framework/concepts are used, and how change is conceptualised and measured. It is organised in five sections. The first concerns visibility and awareness about the OMC; the second analyses research on the EU level coordination process; the third scrutinizes how features of the OMC have been analysed. The fourth and fifth sections, addressing how national integration of the OMC has been researched, respectively address substantive policy change as well as national policy-making. Strikingly, virtually all OMC research adopts theoretical frameworks derived from literature on Europeanisation and/or institutionalisation. Also, as the OMC is voluntary and sanction-free, it depends heavily on how and the the extent to which actors use it (agenda-setting, conflict resolution, maintaining focus on a policy issue, developing a policy dialogue, etc). OMC research has become nuanced and does highlight how, for which purpose and with which outcome actors engage with the OMC. Another finding is that there is data on policy issues addressed through the OMC, learning does take place and there is knowledge about domestic policy problems. However, the linkage between knowledge of an issue and direct use of the OMC for policy change in social policy is weak, but that may change with EU2020, where social policy has received a higher profile. Most research covers the EU-15, much more research needs to be undertaken in newer EU member states.",
keywords = "OMC, Social inclusion, Pensions, Health care and care for the elderly, Theoretical approach, Methods, Indicators, Measurement",
author = "{de la Porte}, Caroline",
year = "2010",
language = "English",
series = "Working Papers on the Reconciliation of Work and Welfare in Europe",
publisher = "The University of Edinburgh",
number = "REC-WP 15/10",
address = "United Kingdom",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "The University of Edinburgh",

}

State of the Art : Overview of Concepts, Indicators and Methodologies Used for Analyzing the Social OMCs. / de la Porte, Caroline.

Edinburgh : The University of Edinburgh, 2010.

Research output: Working paperResearchpeer-review

TY - UNPB

T1 - State of the Art

T2 - Overview of Concepts, Indicators and Methodologies Used for Analyzing the Social OMCs

AU - de la Porte, Caroline

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - This paper is a detailed analysis about the literature on the Social OMC from 2006-2010, focusing on how OMC research has been carried out. It specifically points to which theoretical framework/concepts are used, and how change is conceptualised and measured. It is organised in five sections. The first concerns visibility and awareness about the OMC; the second analyses research on the EU level coordination process; the third scrutinizes how features of the OMC have been analysed. The fourth and fifth sections, addressing how national integration of the OMC has been researched, respectively address substantive policy change as well as national policy-making. Strikingly, virtually all OMC research adopts theoretical frameworks derived from literature on Europeanisation and/or institutionalisation. Also, as the OMC is voluntary and sanction-free, it depends heavily on how and the the extent to which actors use it (agenda-setting, conflict resolution, maintaining focus on a policy issue, developing a policy dialogue, etc). OMC research has become nuanced and does highlight how, for which purpose and with which outcome actors engage with the OMC. Another finding is that there is data on policy issues addressed through the OMC, learning does take place and there is knowledge about domestic policy problems. However, the linkage between knowledge of an issue and direct use of the OMC for policy change in social policy is weak, but that may change with EU2020, where social policy has received a higher profile. Most research covers the EU-15, much more research needs to be undertaken in newer EU member states.

AB - This paper is a detailed analysis about the literature on the Social OMC from 2006-2010, focusing on how OMC research has been carried out. It specifically points to which theoretical framework/concepts are used, and how change is conceptualised and measured. It is organised in five sections. The first concerns visibility and awareness about the OMC; the second analyses research on the EU level coordination process; the third scrutinizes how features of the OMC have been analysed. The fourth and fifth sections, addressing how national integration of the OMC has been researched, respectively address substantive policy change as well as national policy-making. Strikingly, virtually all OMC research adopts theoretical frameworks derived from literature on Europeanisation and/or institutionalisation. Also, as the OMC is voluntary and sanction-free, it depends heavily on how and the the extent to which actors use it (agenda-setting, conflict resolution, maintaining focus on a policy issue, developing a policy dialogue, etc). OMC research has become nuanced and does highlight how, for which purpose and with which outcome actors engage with the OMC. Another finding is that there is data on policy issues addressed through the OMC, learning does take place and there is knowledge about domestic policy problems. However, the linkage between knowledge of an issue and direct use of the OMC for policy change in social policy is weak, but that may change with EU2020, where social policy has received a higher profile. Most research covers the EU-15, much more research needs to be undertaken in newer EU member states.

KW - OMC

KW - Social inclusion

KW - Pensions

KW - Health care and care for the elderly

KW - Theoretical approach

KW - Methods

KW - Indicators

KW - Measurement

UR - http://www.socialpolicy.ed.ac.uk/recwowepudisc/working_papers/rec-wp_15_10

M3 - Working paper

T3 - Working Papers on the Reconciliation of Work and Welfare in Europe

BT - State of the Art

PB - The University of Edinburgh

CY - Edinburgh

ER -