Predictors and Portfolios Over the Life Cycle

Holger Kraft, Claus Munk, Farina Weiss

Research output: Working paperResearch

Abstract

In a calibrated consumption-portfolio model with stock, housing, and labor income predictability, we evaluate the welfare effects of predictability on life-cycle consumption-portfolio choice. We compare skilled investors who are able to take advantage of all sources of predictability with unskilled investors ignoring predictability. For an unskilled investor the certainty equivalent of wealth is 0.3-6.8% lower than for a skilled investor, depending on the market entry date. We also determine the effect of luck to enter the market at a favorable time. Across market entry dates, skilled but unlucky investors can lose up to 15.4% compared to unskilled but lucky investors. Simulation studies confirm the relative importance of luck and document that, if anything, housing predictability is more important than stock predictability.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationTilburg
PublisherNetspar
Number of pages59
Publication statusPublished - 2016
SeriesNetspar Discussion Paper
Number01/2016-010
SeriesSAFE Working Paper
Number139

Keywords

  • Return predictability
  • Scenarios
  • Welfare
  • Performance
  • Housing

Cite this

Kraft, H., Munk, C., & Weiss, F. (2016). Predictors and Portfolios Over the Life Cycle. Tilburg: Netspar. Netspar Discussion Paper, No. 01/2016-010, SAFE Working Paper, No. 139
Kraft, Holger ; Munk, Claus ; Weiss, Farina. / Predictors and Portfolios Over the Life Cycle. Tilburg : Netspar, 2016. (Netspar Discussion Paper; No. 01/2016-010). (SAFE Working Paper; No. 139).
@techreport{c02835107b5b478b8eb34f6f198085e4,
title = "Predictors and Portfolios Over the Life Cycle",
abstract = "In a calibrated consumption-portfolio model with stock, housing, and labor income predictability, we evaluate the welfare effects of predictability on life-cycle consumption-portfolio choice. We compare skilled investors who are able to take advantage of all sources of predictability with unskilled investors ignoring predictability. For an unskilled investor the certainty equivalent of wealth is 0.3-6.8{\%} lower than for a skilled investor, depending on the market entry date. We also determine the effect of luck to enter the market at a favorable time. Across market entry dates, skilled but unlucky investors can lose up to 15.4{\%} compared to unskilled but lucky investors. Simulation studies confirm the relative importance of luck and document that, if anything, housing predictability is more important than stock predictability.",
keywords = "Return predictability, Scenarios, Welfare, Performance, Housing, Return predictability, Scenarios, Welfare, Performance, Housing",
author = "Holger Kraft and Claus Munk and Farina Weiss",
year = "2016",
language = "English",
series = "Netspar Discussion Paper",
publisher = "Netspar",
number = "01/2016-010",
address = "Netherlands",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Netspar",

}

Kraft, H, Munk, C & Weiss, F 2016 'Predictors and Portfolios Over the Life Cycle' Netspar, Tilburg.

Predictors and Portfolios Over the Life Cycle. / Kraft, Holger; Munk, Claus; Weiss, Farina.

Tilburg : Netspar, 2016.

Research output: Working paperResearch

TY - UNPB

T1 - Predictors and Portfolios Over the Life Cycle

AU - Kraft, Holger

AU - Munk, Claus

AU - Weiss, Farina

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - In a calibrated consumption-portfolio model with stock, housing, and labor income predictability, we evaluate the welfare effects of predictability on life-cycle consumption-portfolio choice. We compare skilled investors who are able to take advantage of all sources of predictability with unskilled investors ignoring predictability. For an unskilled investor the certainty equivalent of wealth is 0.3-6.8% lower than for a skilled investor, depending on the market entry date. We also determine the effect of luck to enter the market at a favorable time. Across market entry dates, skilled but unlucky investors can lose up to 15.4% compared to unskilled but lucky investors. Simulation studies confirm the relative importance of luck and document that, if anything, housing predictability is more important than stock predictability.

AB - In a calibrated consumption-portfolio model with stock, housing, and labor income predictability, we evaluate the welfare effects of predictability on life-cycle consumption-portfolio choice. We compare skilled investors who are able to take advantage of all sources of predictability with unskilled investors ignoring predictability. For an unskilled investor the certainty equivalent of wealth is 0.3-6.8% lower than for a skilled investor, depending on the market entry date. We also determine the effect of luck to enter the market at a favorable time. Across market entry dates, skilled but unlucky investors can lose up to 15.4% compared to unskilled but lucky investors. Simulation studies confirm the relative importance of luck and document that, if anything, housing predictability is more important than stock predictability.

KW - Return predictability

KW - Scenarios

KW - Welfare

KW - Performance

KW - Housing

KW - Return predictability

KW - Scenarios

KW - Welfare

KW - Performance

KW - Housing

M3 - Working paper

T3 - Netspar Discussion Paper

BT - Predictors and Portfolios Over the Life Cycle

PB - Netspar

CY - Tilburg

ER -

Kraft H, Munk C, Weiss F. Predictors and Portfolios Over the Life Cycle. Tilburg: Netspar. 2016.