“Omega-team is Moving to Another Premise over My Dead Body…”: Power as Discursive-material Practice in an IS Project

Riitta Hekkala, Mari-Klara Stein, Matti Rossi

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingArticle in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    Using Foucault's (e.g.,1980) view on discourses and power, this Critical Discourse Analysis study examines how power circulates through material-discursive practices in IS development projects. The findings of this study indicate that one of the key power practices is IS development projects is what we call the 'guaranteeing of equality and rationality' – it sets up the the technical-rational ideal and masks the presence of power and politics in the project. However, as projects progress, often this technical-rational ideal begins to crumble with practices such as 'selective ignoring', 'forbidding', 'hiding', and 'criticizing' emerging – each with their own characteristic linguistic moves and material objects mediating the practices. Each of these practices circulates power through what can be called ‘power-resistance’ cycles – in short, the same practice may be harnessed for achieving one effect (exercising power) or it may be employed for the achievement of an alternative effect (exercising resistance to power).
    Using Foucault's (e.g.,1980) view on discourses and power, this Critical Discourse Analysis study examines how power circulates through material-discursive practices in IS development projects. The findings of this study indicate that one of the key power practices is IS development projects is what we call the 'guaranteeing of equality and rationality' – it sets up the the technical-rational ideal and masks the presence of power and politics in the project. However, as projects progress, often this technical-rational ideal begins to crumble with practices such as 'selective ignoring', 'forbidding', 'hiding', and 'criticizing' emerging – each with their own characteristic linguistic moves and material objects mediating the practices. Each of these practices circulates power through what can be called ‘power-resistance’ cycles – in short, the same practice may be harnessed for achieving one effect (exercising power) or it may be employed for the achievement of an alternative effect (exercising resistance to power).
    LanguageEnglish
    Title of host publicationProceedings of the 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014
    EditorsElena Karahanna, Ananth Srinivasan, Bernard Tan
    Number of pages16
    Place of PublicationAtlanta, GA
    PublisherAssociation for Information Systems. AIS Electronic Library (AISeL)
    Date2014
    StatePublished - 2014
    EventThe 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014: Building a Better World through Information Systems - The University of Auckland Business School, Auckland, New Zealand
    Duration: 14 Dec 201417 Dec 2014
    Conference number: 35
    http://icis2014.aisnet.org/

    Conference

    ConferenceThe 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014
    Number35
    LocationThe University of Auckland Business School
    CountryNew Zealand
    CityAuckland
    Period14/12/201417/12/2014
    Internet address
    SeriesProceedings of the International Conference on Information Systems
    ISSN0000-0033

    Keywords

      Cite this

      Hekkala, R., Stein, M-K., & Rossi, M. (2014). “Omega-team is Moving to Another Premise over My Dead Body…”: Power as Discursive-material Practice in an IS Project. In E. Karahanna, A. Srinivasan, & B. Tan (Eds.), Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014 Atlanta, GA: Association for Information Systems. AIS Electronic Library (AISeL). Proceedings of the International Conference on Information Systems
      Hekkala, Riitta ; Stein, Mari-Klara ; Rossi, Matti. / “Omega-team is Moving to Another Premise over My Dead Body…” : Power as Discursive-material Practice in an IS Project. Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014. editor / Elena Karahanna ; Ananth Srinivasan ; Bernard Tan. Atlanta, GA : Association for Information Systems. AIS Electronic Library (AISeL), 2014. (Proceedings of the International Conference on Information Systems).
      @inproceedings{8057a3e3b7c1467f960d86935f1d24f3,
      title = "“Omega-team is Moving to Another Premise over My Dead Body…”: Power as Discursive-material Practice in an IS Project",
      abstract = "Using Foucault's (e.g.,1980) view on discourses and power, this Critical Discourse Analysis study examines how power circulates through material-discursive practices in IS development projects. The findings of this study indicate that one of the key power practices is IS development projects is what we call the 'guaranteeing of equality and rationality' – it sets up the the technical-rational ideal and masks the presence of power and politics in the project. However, as projects progress, often this technical-rational ideal begins to crumble with practices such as 'selective ignoring', 'forbidding', 'hiding', and 'criticizing' emerging – each with their own characteristic linguistic moves and material objects mediating the practices. Each of these practices circulates power through what can be called ‘power-resistance’ cycles – in short, the same practice may be harnessed for achieving one effect (exercising power) or it may be employed for the achievement of an alternative effect (exercising resistance to power).",
      keywords = "Material-discursive practices, Power, Critical Disc ourse Analysis",
      author = "Riitta Hekkala and Mari-Klara Stein and Matti Rossi",
      year = "2014",
      language = "English",
      editor = "Elena Karahanna and Ananth Srinivasan and Bernard Tan",
      booktitle = "Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014",
      publisher = "Association for Information Systems. AIS Electronic Library (AISeL)",

      }

      Hekkala, R, Stein, M-K & Rossi, M 2014, “Omega-team is Moving to Another Premise over My Dead Body…”: Power as Discursive-material Practice in an IS Project. in E Karahanna, A Srinivasan & B Tan (eds), Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014. Association for Information Systems. AIS Electronic Library (AISeL), Atlanta, GA, Proceedings of the International Conference on Information Systems, The 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014, Auckland, New Zealand, 14/12/2014.

      “Omega-team is Moving to Another Premise over My Dead Body…” : Power as Discursive-material Practice in an IS Project. / Hekkala, Riitta; Stein, Mari-Klara; Rossi, Matti.

      Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014. ed. / Elena Karahanna; Ananth Srinivasan; Bernard Tan. Atlanta, GA : Association for Information Systems. AIS Electronic Library (AISeL), 2014.

      Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingArticle in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

      TY - GEN

      T1 - “Omega-team is Moving to Another Premise over My Dead Body…”

      T2 - Power as Discursive-material Practice in an IS Project

      AU - Hekkala,Riitta

      AU - Stein,Mari-Klara

      AU - Rossi,Matti

      PY - 2014

      Y1 - 2014

      N2 - Using Foucault's (e.g.,1980) view on discourses and power, this Critical Discourse Analysis study examines how power circulates through material-discursive practices in IS development projects. The findings of this study indicate that one of the key power practices is IS development projects is what we call the 'guaranteeing of equality and rationality' – it sets up the the technical-rational ideal and masks the presence of power and politics in the project. However, as projects progress, often this technical-rational ideal begins to crumble with practices such as 'selective ignoring', 'forbidding', 'hiding', and 'criticizing' emerging – each with their own characteristic linguistic moves and material objects mediating the practices. Each of these practices circulates power through what can be called ‘power-resistance’ cycles – in short, the same practice may be harnessed for achieving one effect (exercising power) or it may be employed for the achievement of an alternative effect (exercising resistance to power).

      AB - Using Foucault's (e.g.,1980) view on discourses and power, this Critical Discourse Analysis study examines how power circulates through material-discursive practices in IS development projects. The findings of this study indicate that one of the key power practices is IS development projects is what we call the 'guaranteeing of equality and rationality' – it sets up the the technical-rational ideal and masks the presence of power and politics in the project. However, as projects progress, often this technical-rational ideal begins to crumble with practices such as 'selective ignoring', 'forbidding', 'hiding', and 'criticizing' emerging – each with their own characteristic linguistic moves and material objects mediating the practices. Each of these practices circulates power through what can be called ‘power-resistance’ cycles – in short, the same practice may be harnessed for achieving one effect (exercising power) or it may be employed for the achievement of an alternative effect (exercising resistance to power).

      KW - Material-discursive practices

      KW - Power

      KW - Critical Disc ourse Analysis

      M3 - Article in proceedings

      BT - Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014

      PB - Association for Information Systems. AIS Electronic Library (AISeL)

      CY - Atlanta, GA

      ER -

      Hekkala R, Stein M-K, Rossi M. “Omega-team is Moving to Another Premise over My Dead Body…”: Power as Discursive-material Practice in an IS Project. In Karahanna E, Srinivasan A, Tan B, editors, Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Information Systems. ICIS 2014. Atlanta, GA: Association for Information Systems. AIS Electronic Library (AISeL). 2014. (Proceedings of the International Conference on Information Systems).