Of Paradigms and Power: British Economic Policy Making Since Thatcher

Martin B. Carstensen, Matthias Matthijs

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    How and why do ruling policy paradigms persist, even in the face of crises or bouts of accumulating evidence that they are not delivering the goods? And how come policy paradigms often undergo significant internal ideational changes instead of it necessarily amounting to a full-blown paradigm shift? Despite the profound impact of Peter Hall’s approach to policy paradigms and social learning, there is a burgeoning consensus that transposing a rudimentary ‘Kuhnian’ understanding of paradigms into the context of public policy making leads to a notion of punctuated equilibrium style shifts as the only game in town. In effect, while Hall’s approach can account for inter-paradigm change with reference to exogenous shocks, it does not allow for significant ideational change to occur intra-paradigm. In order to remedy this, we suggest that the concept of ideational
    power be placed more centrally in the study of policy paradigms. To demonstrate the general applicability of our framework, the paper examines the evolution of British macroeconomic policy making since 1990. We show that various Prime Ministers and their Chancellors were able to reinterpret and redefine the dominant neoliberal understanding of the economy to match their own specific ideas and policy priorities, resulting in significant but gradual ideational change.
    Original languageEnglish
    Publication date2016
    Number of pages36
    Publication statusPublished - 2016
    EventAmerican Political Science Association, APSA Annual Meeting 2016 - Philadelphia, PA, United States
    Duration: 1 Sep 20164 Sep 2016
    https://convention2.allacademic.com/one/apsa/apsa16/index.php?&obf_var=4945031&PHPSESSID=klf4877sp1u4pca5japvqk5s77

    Conference

    ConferenceAmerican Political Science Association, APSA Annual Meeting 2016
    CountryUnited States
    CityPhiladelphia, PA
    Period01/09/201604/09/2016
    Internet address

    Keywords

    • Britain
    • Economic policy
    • Ideas
    • Neoliberalism
    • Paradigms
    • Power

    Cite this

    Carstensen, M. B., & Matthijs, M. (2016). Of Paradigms and Power: British Economic Policy Making Since Thatcher. Paper presented at American Political Science Association, APSA Annual Meeting 2016, Philadelphia, PA, United States.
    Carstensen, Martin B. ; Matthijs, Matthias. / Of Paradigms and Power : British Economic Policy Making Since Thatcher. Paper presented at American Political Science Association, APSA Annual Meeting 2016, Philadelphia, PA, United States.36 p.
    @conference{b55608de61e1471585a87818440133cc,
    title = "Of Paradigms and Power: British Economic Policy Making Since Thatcher",
    abstract = "How and why do ruling policy paradigms persist, even in the face of crises or bouts of accumulating evidence that they are not delivering the goods? And how come policy paradigms often undergo significant internal ideational changes instead of it necessarily amounting to a full-blown paradigm shift? Despite the profound impact of Peter Hall’s approach to policy paradigms and social learning, there is a burgeoning consensus that transposing a rudimentary ‘Kuhnian’ understanding of paradigms into the context of public policy making leads to a notion of punctuated equilibrium style shifts as the only game in town. In effect, while Hall’s approach can account for inter-paradigm change with reference to exogenous shocks, it does not allow for significant ideational change to occur intra-paradigm. In order to remedy this, we suggest that the concept of ideationalpower be placed more centrally in the study of policy paradigms. To demonstrate the general applicability of our framework, the paper examines the evolution of British macroeconomic policy making since 1990. We show that various Prime Ministers and their Chancellors were able to reinterpret and redefine the dominant neoliberal understanding of the economy to match their own specific ideas and policy priorities, resulting in significant but gradual ideational change.",
    keywords = "Britain, Economic policy, Ideas, Neoliberalism, Paradigms, Power, Britain, Economic policy, Ideas, Neoliberalism, Paradigms, Power",
    author = "Carstensen, {Martin B.} and Matthias Matthijs",
    year = "2016",
    language = "English",
    note = "null ; Conference date: 01-09-2016 Through 04-09-2016",
    url = "https://convention2.allacademic.com/one/apsa/apsa16/index.php?&obf_var=4945031&PHPSESSID=klf4877sp1u4pca5japvqk5s77",

    }

    Carstensen, MB & Matthijs, M 2016, 'Of Paradigms and Power: British Economic Policy Making Since Thatcher' Paper presented at, Philadelphia, PA, United States, 01/09/2016 - 04/09/2016, .

    Of Paradigms and Power : British Economic Policy Making Since Thatcher. / Carstensen, Martin B.; Matthijs, Matthias.

    2016. Paper presented at American Political Science Association, APSA Annual Meeting 2016, Philadelphia, PA, United States.

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

    TY - CONF

    T1 - Of Paradigms and Power

    T2 - British Economic Policy Making Since Thatcher

    AU - Carstensen, Martin B.

    AU - Matthijs, Matthias

    PY - 2016

    Y1 - 2016

    N2 - How and why do ruling policy paradigms persist, even in the face of crises or bouts of accumulating evidence that they are not delivering the goods? And how come policy paradigms often undergo significant internal ideational changes instead of it necessarily amounting to a full-blown paradigm shift? Despite the profound impact of Peter Hall’s approach to policy paradigms and social learning, there is a burgeoning consensus that transposing a rudimentary ‘Kuhnian’ understanding of paradigms into the context of public policy making leads to a notion of punctuated equilibrium style shifts as the only game in town. In effect, while Hall’s approach can account for inter-paradigm change with reference to exogenous shocks, it does not allow for significant ideational change to occur intra-paradigm. In order to remedy this, we suggest that the concept of ideationalpower be placed more centrally in the study of policy paradigms. To demonstrate the general applicability of our framework, the paper examines the evolution of British macroeconomic policy making since 1990. We show that various Prime Ministers and their Chancellors were able to reinterpret and redefine the dominant neoliberal understanding of the economy to match their own specific ideas and policy priorities, resulting in significant but gradual ideational change.

    AB - How and why do ruling policy paradigms persist, even in the face of crises or bouts of accumulating evidence that they are not delivering the goods? And how come policy paradigms often undergo significant internal ideational changes instead of it necessarily amounting to a full-blown paradigm shift? Despite the profound impact of Peter Hall’s approach to policy paradigms and social learning, there is a burgeoning consensus that transposing a rudimentary ‘Kuhnian’ understanding of paradigms into the context of public policy making leads to a notion of punctuated equilibrium style shifts as the only game in town. In effect, while Hall’s approach can account for inter-paradigm change with reference to exogenous shocks, it does not allow for significant ideational change to occur intra-paradigm. In order to remedy this, we suggest that the concept of ideationalpower be placed more centrally in the study of policy paradigms. To demonstrate the general applicability of our framework, the paper examines the evolution of British macroeconomic policy making since 1990. We show that various Prime Ministers and their Chancellors were able to reinterpret and redefine the dominant neoliberal understanding of the economy to match their own specific ideas and policy priorities, resulting in significant but gradual ideational change.

    KW - Britain

    KW - Economic policy

    KW - Ideas

    KW - Neoliberalism

    KW - Paradigms

    KW - Power

    KW - Britain

    KW - Economic policy

    KW - Ideas

    KW - Neoliberalism

    KW - Paradigms

    KW - Power

    M3 - Paper

    ER -

    Carstensen MB, Matthijs M. Of Paradigms and Power: British Economic Policy Making Since Thatcher. 2016. Paper presented at American Political Science Association, APSA Annual Meeting 2016, Philadelphia, PA, United States.