Objective Measures of the Built Environment and Physical Activity in Children: From Walkability to Moveability

Christoph Buck, Tobias Tkaczick, Yannis Pitsiladis, Ilse De Bourdehaudhuij, Lucia Reisch, Wolfgang Ahrens, Iris Pigeot

    Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    Features of the built environment that may influence physical activity (PA) levels are commonly captured using a so-called walkability index. Since such indices typically describe opportunities for walking in everyday life of adults, they might not be applicable to assess urban opportunities for PA in children. Particularly, the spatial availability of recreational facilities may have an impact on PA in children and should be additionally considered. We linked individual data of 400 2- to 9-year-old children recruited in the European IDEFICS study to geographic data of one German study region, based on individual network-dependent neighborhoods. Environmental features of the walkability concept and the availability of recreational facilities, i.e. playgrounds, green spaces, and parks, were measured. Relevant features were combined to a moveability index that should capture urban opportunities for PA in children. A gamma log-regression model was used to model linear and non-linear effects of individual variables on accelerometer-based moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) stratified by pre-school children (<6 years) and school children (≥6 years). Single environmental features and the resulting indices were separately included into the model to investigate the effect of each variable on MVPA. In school children, commonly used features such as residential density (βˆ=0.5⋅10−4,p=0.02) , intersection density (βˆ=0.003,p=0.04) , and public transit density (βˆ=0.037,p=0.01) showed a positive effect on MVPA, while land use mix revealed a negative effect on MVPA (βˆ=−0.173,p=0.13) . In particular, playground density (βˆ=0.048,p=0.01) and density of public open spaces, i.e., playgrounds and parks combined (βˆ=0.040,p=0.01) , showed positive effects on MVPA. However, availability of green spaces showed no effect on MVPA. Different moveability indices were constructed based on the walkability index accounting for the negative impact of land use mix. Moveability indices showed also strong effects on MVPA in school children for both components, expanded by playground density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.008) or by public open space density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.007) , but no effects of urban measures and moveability indices were found in pre-school children. The final moveability indices capture relevant opportunities for PA in school children. Particularly, availability of public open spaces seems to be a strong predictor of MVPA. Future studies involving children should consider quantitative assessment of public recreational facilities in larger cities or urban sprawls in order to investigate the influence of the moveability on childhood PA in a broader sample.
    Features of the built environment that may influence physical activity (PA) levels are commonly captured using a so-called walkability index. Since such indices typically describe opportunities for walking in everyday life of adults, they might not be applicable to assess urban opportunities for PA in children. Particularly, the spatial availability of recreational facilities may have an impact on PA in children and should be additionally considered. We linked individual data of 400 2- to 9-year-old children recruited in the European IDEFICS study to geographic data of one German study region, based on individual network-dependent neighborhoods. Environmental features of the walkability concept and the availability of recreational facilities, i.e. playgrounds, green spaces, and parks, were measured. Relevant features were combined to a moveability index that should capture urban opportunities for PA in children. A gamma log-regression model was used to model linear and non-linear effects of individual variables on accelerometer-based moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) stratified by pre-school children (<6 years) and school children (≥6 years). Single environmental features and the resulting indices were separately included into the model to investigate the effect of each variable on MVPA. In school children, commonly used features such as residential density (βˆ=0.5⋅10−4,p=0.02) , intersection density (βˆ=0.003,p=0.04) , and public transit density (βˆ=0.037,p=0.01) showed a positive effect on MVPA, while land use mix revealed a negative effect on MVPA (βˆ=−0.173,p=0.13) . In particular, playground density (βˆ=0.048,p=0.01) and density of public open spaces, i.e., playgrounds and parks combined (βˆ=0.040,p=0.01) , showed positive effects on MVPA. However, availability of green spaces showed no effect on MVPA. Different moveability indices were constructed based on the walkability index accounting for the negative impact of land use mix. Moveability indices showed also strong effects on MVPA in school children for both components, expanded by playground density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.008) or by public open space density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.007) , but no effects of urban measures and moveability indices were found in pre-school children. The final moveability indices capture relevant opportunities for PA in school children. Particularly, availability of public open spaces seems to be a strong predictor of MVPA. Future studies involving children should consider quantitative assessment of public recreational facilities in larger cities or urban sprawls in order to investigate the influence of the moveability on childhood PA in a broader sample.
    LanguageEnglish
    JournalJournal of Urban Health
    Volume92
    Issue number1
    Pages24-38
    Number of pages15
    ISSN1099-3460
    DOIs
    StatePublished - 2015

    Keywords

      Cite this

      Buck, C., Tkaczick, T., Pitsiladis, Y., De Bourdehaudhuij, I., Reisch, L., Ahrens, W., & Pigeot, I. (2015). Objective Measures of the Built Environment and Physical Activity in Children: From Walkability to Moveability. Journal of Urban Health, 92(1), 24-38. DOI: 10.1007/s11524-014-9915-2
      Buck, Christoph ; Tkaczick, Tobias ; Pitsiladis, Yannis ; De Bourdehaudhuij, Ilse ; Reisch, Lucia ; Ahrens, Wolfgang ; Pigeot, Iris. / Objective Measures of the Built Environment and Physical Activity in Children : From Walkability to Moveability. In: Journal of Urban Health. 2015 ; Vol. 92, No. 1. pp. 24-38
      @article{1ac2c21abef1491eb3b48ae03a8e1854,
      title = "Objective Measures of the Built Environment and Physical Activity in Children: From Walkability to Moveability",
      abstract = "Features of the built environment that may influence physical activity (PA) levels are commonly captured using a so-called walkability index. Since such indices typically describe opportunities for walking in everyday life of adults, they might not be applicable to assess urban opportunities for PA in children. Particularly, the spatial availability of recreational facilities may have an impact on PA in children and should be additionally considered. We linked individual data of 400 2- to 9-year-old children recruited in the European IDEFICS study to geographic data of one German study region, based on individual network-dependent neighborhoods. Environmental features of the walkability concept and the availability of recreational facilities, i.e. playgrounds, green spaces, and parks, were measured. Relevant features were combined to a moveability index that should capture urban opportunities for PA in children. A gamma log-regression model was used to model linear and non-linear effects of individual variables on accelerometer-based moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) stratified by pre-school children (<6 years) and school children (≥6 years). Single environmental features and the resulting indices were separately included into the model to investigate the effect of each variable on MVPA. In school children, commonly used features such as residential density (βˆ=0.5⋅10−4,p=0.02) , intersection density (βˆ=0.003,p=0.04) , and public transit density (βˆ=0.037,p=0.01) showed a positive effect on MVPA, while land use mix revealed a negative effect on MVPA (βˆ=−0.173,p=0.13) . In particular, playground density (βˆ=0.048,p=0.01) and density of public open spaces, i.e., playgrounds and parks combined (βˆ=0.040,p=0.01) , showed positive effects on MVPA. However, availability of green spaces showed no effect on MVPA. Different moveability indices were constructed based on the walkability index accounting for the negative impact of land use mix. Moveability indices showed also strong effects on MVPA in school children for both components, expanded by playground density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.008) or by public open space density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.007) , but no effects of urban measures and moveability indices were found in pre-school children. The final moveability indices capture relevant opportunities for PA in school children. Particularly, availability of public open spaces seems to be a strong predictor of MVPA. Future studies involving children should consider quantitative assessment of public recreational facilities in larger cities or urban sprawls in order to investigate the influence of the moveability on childhood PA in a broader sample.",
      keywords = "Accelerometry, Built environment, Children, IDEFICS study, Moderate-to-vigorous physical activity, Walkability",
      author = "Christoph Buck and Tobias Tkaczick and Yannis Pitsiladis and {De Bourdehaudhuij}, Ilse and Lucia Reisch and Wolfgang Ahrens and Iris Pigeot",
      year = "2015",
      doi = "10.1007/s11524-014-9915-2",
      language = "English",
      volume = "92",
      pages = "24--38",
      journal = "Journal of Urban Health",
      issn = "1099-3460",
      publisher = "Springer",
      number = "1",

      }

      Buck, C, Tkaczick, T, Pitsiladis, Y, De Bourdehaudhuij, I, Reisch, L, Ahrens, W & Pigeot, I 2015, 'Objective Measures of the Built Environment and Physical Activity in Children: From Walkability to Moveability' Journal of Urban Health, vol. 92, no. 1, pp. 24-38. DOI: 10.1007/s11524-014-9915-2

      Objective Measures of the Built Environment and Physical Activity in Children : From Walkability to Moveability. / Buck, Christoph; Tkaczick, Tobias; Pitsiladis, Yannis; De Bourdehaudhuij, Ilse; Reisch, Lucia; Ahrens, Wolfgang; Pigeot, Iris.

      In: Journal of Urban Health, Vol. 92, No. 1, 2015, p. 24-38.

      Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

      TY - JOUR

      T1 - Objective Measures of the Built Environment and Physical Activity in Children

      T2 - Journal of Urban Health

      AU - Buck,Christoph

      AU - Tkaczick,Tobias

      AU - Pitsiladis,Yannis

      AU - De Bourdehaudhuij,Ilse

      AU - Reisch,Lucia

      AU - Ahrens,Wolfgang

      AU - Pigeot,Iris

      PY - 2015

      Y1 - 2015

      N2 - Features of the built environment that may influence physical activity (PA) levels are commonly captured using a so-called walkability index. Since such indices typically describe opportunities for walking in everyday life of adults, they might not be applicable to assess urban opportunities for PA in children. Particularly, the spatial availability of recreational facilities may have an impact on PA in children and should be additionally considered. We linked individual data of 400 2- to 9-year-old children recruited in the European IDEFICS study to geographic data of one German study region, based on individual network-dependent neighborhoods. Environmental features of the walkability concept and the availability of recreational facilities, i.e. playgrounds, green spaces, and parks, were measured. Relevant features were combined to a moveability index that should capture urban opportunities for PA in children. A gamma log-regression model was used to model linear and non-linear effects of individual variables on accelerometer-based moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) stratified by pre-school children (<6 years) and school children (≥6 years). Single environmental features and the resulting indices were separately included into the model to investigate the effect of each variable on MVPA. In school children, commonly used features such as residential density (βˆ=0.5⋅10−4,p=0.02) , intersection density (βˆ=0.003,p=0.04) , and public transit density (βˆ=0.037,p=0.01) showed a positive effect on MVPA, while land use mix revealed a negative effect on MVPA (βˆ=−0.173,p=0.13) . In particular, playground density (βˆ=0.048,p=0.01) and density of public open spaces, i.e., playgrounds and parks combined (βˆ=0.040,p=0.01) , showed positive effects on MVPA. However, availability of green spaces showed no effect on MVPA. Different moveability indices were constructed based on the walkability index accounting for the negative impact of land use mix. Moveability indices showed also strong effects on MVPA in school children for both components, expanded by playground density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.008) or by public open space density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.007) , but no effects of urban measures and moveability indices were found in pre-school children. The final moveability indices capture relevant opportunities for PA in school children. Particularly, availability of public open spaces seems to be a strong predictor of MVPA. Future studies involving children should consider quantitative assessment of public recreational facilities in larger cities or urban sprawls in order to investigate the influence of the moveability on childhood PA in a broader sample.

      AB - Features of the built environment that may influence physical activity (PA) levels are commonly captured using a so-called walkability index. Since such indices typically describe opportunities for walking in everyday life of adults, they might not be applicable to assess urban opportunities for PA in children. Particularly, the spatial availability of recreational facilities may have an impact on PA in children and should be additionally considered. We linked individual data of 400 2- to 9-year-old children recruited in the European IDEFICS study to geographic data of one German study region, based on individual network-dependent neighborhoods. Environmental features of the walkability concept and the availability of recreational facilities, i.e. playgrounds, green spaces, and parks, were measured. Relevant features were combined to a moveability index that should capture urban opportunities for PA in children. A gamma log-regression model was used to model linear and non-linear effects of individual variables on accelerometer-based moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) stratified by pre-school children (<6 years) and school children (≥6 years). Single environmental features and the resulting indices were separately included into the model to investigate the effect of each variable on MVPA. In school children, commonly used features such as residential density (βˆ=0.5⋅10−4,p=0.02) , intersection density (βˆ=0.003,p=0.04) , and public transit density (βˆ=0.037,p=0.01) showed a positive effect on MVPA, while land use mix revealed a negative effect on MVPA (βˆ=−0.173,p=0.13) . In particular, playground density (βˆ=0.048,p=0.01) and density of public open spaces, i.e., playgrounds and parks combined (βˆ=0.040,p=0.01) , showed positive effects on MVPA. However, availability of green spaces showed no effect on MVPA. Different moveability indices were constructed based on the walkability index accounting for the negative impact of land use mix. Moveability indices showed also strong effects on MVPA in school children for both components, expanded by playground density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.008) or by public open space density (βˆ=0.014,p=0.007) , but no effects of urban measures and moveability indices were found in pre-school children. The final moveability indices capture relevant opportunities for PA in school children. Particularly, availability of public open spaces seems to be a strong predictor of MVPA. Future studies involving children should consider quantitative assessment of public recreational facilities in larger cities or urban sprawls in order to investigate the influence of the moveability on childhood PA in a broader sample.

      KW - Accelerometry

      KW - Built environment

      KW - Children

      KW - IDEFICS study

      KW - Moderate-to-vigorous physical activity

      KW - Walkability

      UR - http://sfx-45cbs.hosted.exlibrisgroup.com/45cbs?url_ver=Z39.88-2004&url_ctx_fmt=info:ofi/fmt:kev:mtx:ctx&ctx_enc=info:ofi/enc:UTF-8&ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&rfr_id=info:sid/sfxit.com:azlist&sfx.ignore_date_threshold=1&rft.object_id=954925610936&rft.object_portfolio_id=&svc.holdings=yes&svc.fulltext=yes

      U2 - 10.1007/s11524-014-9915-2

      DO - 10.1007/s11524-014-9915-2

      M3 - Journal article

      VL - 92

      SP - 24

      EP - 38

      JO - Journal of Urban Health

      JF - Journal of Urban Health

      SN - 1099-3460

      IS - 1

      ER -

      Buck C, Tkaczick T, Pitsiladis Y, De Bourdehaudhuij I, Reisch L, Ahrens W et al. Objective Measures of the Built Environment and Physical Activity in Children: From Walkability to Moveability. Journal of Urban Health. 2015;92(1):24-38. Available from, DOI: 10.1007/s11524-014-9915-2