Neurocomputational Mechanisms at Play when Weighing Concerns for Extrinsic Rewards, Moral Values, and Social Image

Chen Qu, Elise Météreau, Luigi Butera, Marie Claire Villeval, Jean Claude Dreher

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Humans not only value extrinsic monetary rewards but also their own morality and their image in the eyes of others. Yet violating moral norms is frequent, especially when people know that they are not under scrutiny. When moral values and monetary payoffs are at odds, how does the brain weigh the benefits and costs of moral and monetary payoffs? Here, using a neurocomputational model of decision value (DV) and functional (f)MRI, we investigated whether different brain systems are engaged when deciding whether to earn money by contributing to a bad cause and when deciding whether to sacrifice money to contribute to a good cause, both when such choices were made privately or in public. Although similar principles of DV computations were used to solve these dilemmas, they engaged 2 distinct valuation systems. When weighing monetary benefits and moral costs, people were willing to trade their moral values in exchange for money, an effect accompanied by DV computation engaging the anterior insula and the lateral prefrontal cortex (PFC). In contrast, weighing monetary costs against compliance with one's moral values engaged the ventral putamen. Moreover, regardless of the type of dilemma, a brain network including the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), anterior insula, and the right temporoparietal junction (TJP) was more engaged in public than in private settings. Together, these findings identify how the brain processes three sources of motivation: extrinsic rewards, moral values, and concerns for image.
Original languageEnglish
Article numbere3000283
JournalPLOS Biology
Volume17
Issue number6
Number of pages27
ISSN1544-9173
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2019

Cite this

Qu, Chen ; Météreau, Elise ; Butera, Luigi ; Villeval, Marie Claire ; Dreher, Jean Claude. / Neurocomputational Mechanisms at Play when Weighing Concerns for Extrinsic Rewards, Moral Values, and Social Image. In: PLOS Biology. 2019 ; Vol. 17, No. 6.
@article{c7de8b0f4eae49d6883660611784de1c,
title = "Neurocomputational Mechanisms at Play when Weighing Concerns for Extrinsic Rewards, Moral Values, and Social Image",
abstract = "Humans not only value extrinsic monetary rewards but also their own morality and their image in the eyes of others. Yet violating moral norms is frequent, especially when people know that they are not under scrutiny. When moral values and monetary payoffs are at odds, how does the brain weigh the benefits and costs of moral and monetary payoffs? Here, using a neurocomputational model of decision value (DV) and functional (f)MRI, we investigated whether different brain systems are engaged when deciding whether to earn money by contributing to a bad cause and when deciding whether to sacrifice money to contribute to a good cause, both when such choices were made privately or in public. Although similar principles of DV computations were used to solve these dilemmas, they engaged 2 distinct valuation systems. When weighing monetary benefits and moral costs, people were willing to trade their moral values in exchange for money, an effect accompanied by DV computation engaging the anterior insula and the lateral prefrontal cortex (PFC). In contrast, weighing monetary costs against compliance with one's moral values engaged the ventral putamen. Moreover, regardless of the type of dilemma, a brain network including the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), anterior insula, and the right temporoparietal junction (TJP) was more engaged in public than in private settings. Together, these findings identify how the brain processes three sources of motivation: extrinsic rewards, moral values, and concerns for image.",
author = "Chen Qu and Elise M{\'e}t{\'e}reau and Luigi Butera and Villeval, {Marie Claire} and Dreher, {Jean Claude}",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pbio.3000283",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
journal = "PLOS Biology",
issn = "1544-9173",
publisher = "Public Library of Science",
number = "6",

}

Neurocomputational Mechanisms at Play when Weighing Concerns for Extrinsic Rewards, Moral Values, and Social Image. / Qu, Chen; Météreau, Elise; Butera, Luigi; Villeval, Marie Claire; Dreher, Jean Claude.

In: PLOS Biology, Vol. 17, No. 6, e3000283, 06.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Neurocomputational Mechanisms at Play when Weighing Concerns for Extrinsic Rewards, Moral Values, and Social Image

AU - Qu, Chen

AU - Météreau, Elise

AU - Butera, Luigi

AU - Villeval, Marie Claire

AU - Dreher, Jean Claude

PY - 2019/6

Y1 - 2019/6

N2 - Humans not only value extrinsic monetary rewards but also their own morality and their image in the eyes of others. Yet violating moral norms is frequent, especially when people know that they are not under scrutiny. When moral values and monetary payoffs are at odds, how does the brain weigh the benefits and costs of moral and monetary payoffs? Here, using a neurocomputational model of decision value (DV) and functional (f)MRI, we investigated whether different brain systems are engaged when deciding whether to earn money by contributing to a bad cause and when deciding whether to sacrifice money to contribute to a good cause, both when such choices were made privately or in public. Although similar principles of DV computations were used to solve these dilemmas, they engaged 2 distinct valuation systems. When weighing monetary benefits and moral costs, people were willing to trade their moral values in exchange for money, an effect accompanied by DV computation engaging the anterior insula and the lateral prefrontal cortex (PFC). In contrast, weighing monetary costs against compliance with one's moral values engaged the ventral putamen. Moreover, regardless of the type of dilemma, a brain network including the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), anterior insula, and the right temporoparietal junction (TJP) was more engaged in public than in private settings. Together, these findings identify how the brain processes three sources of motivation: extrinsic rewards, moral values, and concerns for image.

AB - Humans not only value extrinsic monetary rewards but also their own morality and their image in the eyes of others. Yet violating moral norms is frequent, especially when people know that they are not under scrutiny. When moral values and monetary payoffs are at odds, how does the brain weigh the benefits and costs of moral and monetary payoffs? Here, using a neurocomputational model of decision value (DV) and functional (f)MRI, we investigated whether different brain systems are engaged when deciding whether to earn money by contributing to a bad cause and when deciding whether to sacrifice money to contribute to a good cause, both when such choices were made privately or in public. Although similar principles of DV computations were used to solve these dilemmas, they engaged 2 distinct valuation systems. When weighing monetary benefits and moral costs, people were willing to trade their moral values in exchange for money, an effect accompanied by DV computation engaging the anterior insula and the lateral prefrontal cortex (PFC). In contrast, weighing monetary costs against compliance with one's moral values engaged the ventral putamen. Moreover, regardless of the type of dilemma, a brain network including the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), anterior insula, and the right temporoparietal junction (TJP) was more engaged in public than in private settings. Together, these findings identify how the brain processes three sources of motivation: extrinsic rewards, moral values, and concerns for image.

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pbio.3000283

DO - 10.1371/journal.pbio.3000283

M3 - Journal article

VL - 17

JO - PLOS Biology

JF - PLOS Biology

SN - 1544-9173

IS - 6

M1 - e3000283

ER -