Narrating Illegal Logging Across the Globe: Between Green Protectionism and Sustainable Resource Use

Georg Winkel, Sina Leipold, Karin Buhmann, Ben Cashore, Wil de Jong, Iben Nathan, Metodi Sotirov, Michael Stone

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

87 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

In the last decade illegal logging has triggered the attention of policy makers and scholars of international forest governance. The issue is multifaceted, involving aspects of social and environmental sustainability, development, trade, access to markets and competitiveness. A vivid academic debate has resulted, exploring the nexus between markets and trade on one hand, and environmental and social sustainability on the other. The purpose of this paper is systematically assess the international policy discourse on illegal logging and legality verification policies in different regions of the world, drawing on the concept of policy narratives. Specifically, we analyse and compare policy narratives in Australia, Cambodia, China, the EU, Indonesia, Peru and the US. Our analysis is grounded on a rich empirical basis consisting of 260 interviews conducted by various researchers, numerous conversations with practitioners, policy documents and a media analysis. We find striking differences across the globe in narratives about illegal logging and legality verification and conclude that these need to be considered when assessing the support for, and the current and potential effects of, the emerging legality verification regime.
Original languageEnglish
JournalInternational Forestry Review
Volume19
Issue numberSupplement 1
Pages (from-to)81-97
Number of pages17
ISSN1465-5489
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2017

Bibliographical note

Published online: November 22, 2017

Keywords

  • Global forest governance
  • Legality verification
  • Narratives
  • Illegal logging
  • Forest policy

Cite this

Winkel, Georg ; Leipold, Sina ; Buhmann, Karin ; Cashore, Ben ; de Jong, Wil ; Nathan, Iben ; Sotirov, Metodi ; Stone, Michael. / Narrating Illegal Logging Across the Globe : Between Green Protectionism and Sustainable Resource Use. In: International Forestry Review. 2017 ; Vol. 19, No. Supplement 1. pp. 81-97.
@article{9809f85c61e94fe29ff36217d6d8a477,
title = "Narrating Illegal Logging Across the Globe: Between Green Protectionism and Sustainable Resource Use",
abstract = "In the last decade illegal logging has triggered the attention of policy makers and scholars of international forest governance. The issue is multifaceted, involving aspects of social and environmental sustainability, development, trade, access to markets and competitiveness. A vivid academic debate has resulted, exploring the nexus between markets and trade on one hand, and environmental and social sustainability on the other. The purpose of this paper is systematically assess the international policy discourse on illegal logging and legality verification policies in different regions of the world, drawing on the concept of policy narratives. Specifically, we analyse and compare policy narratives in Australia, Cambodia, China, the EU, Indonesia, Peru and the US. Our analysis is grounded on a rich empirical basis consisting of 260 interviews conducted by various researchers, numerous conversations with practitioners, policy documents and a media analysis. We find striking differences across the globe in narratives about illegal logging and legality verification and conclude that these need to be considered when assessing the support for, and the current and potential effects of, the emerging legality verification regime.",
keywords = "Global forest governance, Legality verification, Narratives, Illegal logging, Forest policy, Global forest governance, Legality verification, Narratives, Illegal logging, Forest policy",
author = "Georg Winkel and Sina Leipold and Karin Buhmann and Ben Cashore and {de Jong}, Wil and Iben Nathan and Metodi Sotirov and Michael Stone",
note = "Published online: November 22, 2017",
year = "2017",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1505/146554817822407367",
language = "English",
volume = "19",
pages = "81--97",
journal = "International Forestry Review",
issn = "1465-5489",
publisher = "Commonwealth Forestry Associaion",
number = "Supplement 1",

}

Winkel, G, Leipold, S, Buhmann, K, Cashore, B, de Jong, W, Nathan, I, Sotirov, M & Stone, M 2017, 'Narrating Illegal Logging Across the Globe: Between Green Protectionism and Sustainable Resource Use', International Forestry Review, vol. 19, no. Supplement 1, pp. 81-97. https://doi.org/10.1505/146554817822407367

Narrating Illegal Logging Across the Globe : Between Green Protectionism and Sustainable Resource Use. / Winkel, Georg; Leipold, Sina; Buhmann, Karin ; Cashore, Ben; de Jong, Wil; Nathan, Iben; Sotirov, Metodi; Stone, Michael.

In: International Forestry Review, Vol. 19, No. Supplement 1, 12.2017, p. 81-97.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Narrating Illegal Logging Across the Globe

T2 - Between Green Protectionism and Sustainable Resource Use

AU - Winkel, Georg

AU - Leipold, Sina

AU - Buhmann, Karin

AU - Cashore, Ben

AU - de Jong, Wil

AU - Nathan, Iben

AU - Sotirov, Metodi

AU - Stone, Michael

N1 - Published online: November 22, 2017

PY - 2017/12

Y1 - 2017/12

N2 - In the last decade illegal logging has triggered the attention of policy makers and scholars of international forest governance. The issue is multifaceted, involving aspects of social and environmental sustainability, development, trade, access to markets and competitiveness. A vivid academic debate has resulted, exploring the nexus between markets and trade on one hand, and environmental and social sustainability on the other. The purpose of this paper is systematically assess the international policy discourse on illegal logging and legality verification policies in different regions of the world, drawing on the concept of policy narratives. Specifically, we analyse and compare policy narratives in Australia, Cambodia, China, the EU, Indonesia, Peru and the US. Our analysis is grounded on a rich empirical basis consisting of 260 interviews conducted by various researchers, numerous conversations with practitioners, policy documents and a media analysis. We find striking differences across the globe in narratives about illegal logging and legality verification and conclude that these need to be considered when assessing the support for, and the current and potential effects of, the emerging legality verification regime.

AB - In the last decade illegal logging has triggered the attention of policy makers and scholars of international forest governance. The issue is multifaceted, involving aspects of social and environmental sustainability, development, trade, access to markets and competitiveness. A vivid academic debate has resulted, exploring the nexus between markets and trade on one hand, and environmental and social sustainability on the other. The purpose of this paper is systematically assess the international policy discourse on illegal logging and legality verification policies in different regions of the world, drawing on the concept of policy narratives. Specifically, we analyse and compare policy narratives in Australia, Cambodia, China, the EU, Indonesia, Peru and the US. Our analysis is grounded on a rich empirical basis consisting of 260 interviews conducted by various researchers, numerous conversations with practitioners, policy documents and a media analysis. We find striking differences across the globe in narratives about illegal logging and legality verification and conclude that these need to be considered when assessing the support for, and the current and potential effects of, the emerging legality verification regime.

KW - Global forest governance

KW - Legality verification

KW - Narratives

KW - Illegal logging

KW - Forest policy

KW - Global forest governance

KW - Legality verification

KW - Narratives

KW - Illegal logging

KW - Forest policy

U2 - 10.1505/146554817822407367

DO - 10.1505/146554817822407367

M3 - Journal article

VL - 19

SP - 81

EP - 97

JO - International Forestry Review

JF - International Forestry Review

SN - 1465-5489

IS - Supplement 1

ER -