Metaphors in Managerial and Employee Sensemaking in an Information Systems Project

Riitta Hekkala, Mari-Klara Stein, Matti Rossi

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This longitudinal study looks at the metaphors used in a public sector information systems development project from the perspective of cognitive metaphor theory (Lakoff & Johnson,). We examine the use of metaphors by project team members, including representatives of the users, software developers and the managers guiding the project work. The findings indicate that project team members and managers use a rich set of metaphors to make sense of the project and the records management system they are working on. Notably, distinct sets of metaphors are used in different project phases and among the project personnel and management. As the differences in the metaphors also coincide with key events in the trajectory of the project, we contend that metaphors have significant power in sensemaking, influencing action and project outcomes. In particular, we find that in highly ambiguous, knowledge-intensive situations, metaphor use with unclear intentions and purpose hinders learning and creates more chaos than order. From a practical perspective, our study highlights the relevance of metaphor use for project management. We suggest that intentional selection of metaphors by management could be beneficial for many complex information systems projects.
This longitudinal study looks at the metaphors used in a public sector information systems development project from the perspective of cognitive metaphor theory (Lakoff & Johnson,). We examine the use of metaphors by project team members, including representatives of the users, software developers and the managers guiding the project work. The findings indicate that project team members and managers use a rich set of metaphors to make sense of the project and the records management system they are working on. Notably, distinct sets of metaphors are used in different project phases and among the project personnel and management. As the differences in the metaphors also coincide with key events in the trajectory of the project, we contend that metaphors have significant power in sensemaking, influencing action and project outcomes. In particular, we find that in highly ambiguous, knowledge-intensive situations, metaphor use with unclear intentions and purpose hinders learning and creates more chaos than order. From a practical perspective, our study highlights the relevance of metaphor use for project management. We suggest that intentional selection of metaphors by management could be beneficial for many complex information systems projects.
LanguageEnglish
JournalInformation Systems Journal
Volume28
Issue number1
Pages142-174
Number of pages33
ISSN1350-1917
DOIs
StatePublished - 2018

Keywords

  • Cognitive metaphor theory
  • Information systems development
  • Metaphors
  • Qualitative case study
  • Sensemaking

Cite this

@article{5f2a8f597c6249b5800abbaf3d1ca7a0,
title = "Metaphors in Managerial and Employee Sensemaking in an Information Systems Project",
abstract = "This longitudinal study looks at the metaphors used in a public sector information systems development project from the perspective of cognitive metaphor theory (Lakoff & Johnson,). We examine the use of metaphors by project team members, including representatives of the users, software developers and the managers guiding the project work. The findings indicate that project team members and managers use a rich set of metaphors to make sense of the project and the records management system they are working on. Notably, distinct sets of metaphors are used in different project phases and among the project personnel and management. As the differences in the metaphors also coincide with key events in the trajectory of the project, we contend that metaphors have significant power in sensemaking, influencing action and project outcomes. In particular, we find that in highly ambiguous, knowledge-intensive situations, metaphor use with unclear intentions and purpose hinders learning and creates more chaos than order. From a practical perspective, our study highlights the relevance of metaphor use for project management. We suggest that intentional selection of metaphors by management could be beneficial for many complex information systems projects.",
keywords = "Cognitive metaphor theory, Information systems development, Metaphors, Qualitative case study, Sensemaking, Cognitive metaphor theory, Information systems development, Metaphors, Qualitative case study, Sensemaking",
author = "Riitta Hekkala and Mari-Klara Stein and Matti Rossi",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.1111/isj.12133",
language = "English",
volume = "28",
pages = "142--174",
journal = "Information Systems Journal",
issn = "1350-1917",
publisher = "Blackwell Publishing",
number = "1",

}

Metaphors in Managerial and Employee Sensemaking in an Information Systems Project. / Hekkala, Riitta; Stein, Mari-Klara; Rossi, Matti.

In: Information Systems Journal, Vol. 28, No. 1, 2018, p. 142-174.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Metaphors in Managerial and Employee Sensemaking in an Information Systems Project

AU - Hekkala,Riitta

AU - Stein,Mari-Klara

AU - Rossi,Matti

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - This longitudinal study looks at the metaphors used in a public sector information systems development project from the perspective of cognitive metaphor theory (Lakoff & Johnson,). We examine the use of metaphors by project team members, including representatives of the users, software developers and the managers guiding the project work. The findings indicate that project team members and managers use a rich set of metaphors to make sense of the project and the records management system they are working on. Notably, distinct sets of metaphors are used in different project phases and among the project personnel and management. As the differences in the metaphors also coincide with key events in the trajectory of the project, we contend that metaphors have significant power in sensemaking, influencing action and project outcomes. In particular, we find that in highly ambiguous, knowledge-intensive situations, metaphor use with unclear intentions and purpose hinders learning and creates more chaos than order. From a practical perspective, our study highlights the relevance of metaphor use for project management. We suggest that intentional selection of metaphors by management could be beneficial for many complex information systems projects.

AB - This longitudinal study looks at the metaphors used in a public sector information systems development project from the perspective of cognitive metaphor theory (Lakoff & Johnson,). We examine the use of metaphors by project team members, including representatives of the users, software developers and the managers guiding the project work. The findings indicate that project team members and managers use a rich set of metaphors to make sense of the project and the records management system they are working on. Notably, distinct sets of metaphors are used in different project phases and among the project personnel and management. As the differences in the metaphors also coincide with key events in the trajectory of the project, we contend that metaphors have significant power in sensemaking, influencing action and project outcomes. In particular, we find that in highly ambiguous, knowledge-intensive situations, metaphor use with unclear intentions and purpose hinders learning and creates more chaos than order. From a practical perspective, our study highlights the relevance of metaphor use for project management. We suggest that intentional selection of metaphors by management could be beneficial for many complex information systems projects.

KW - Cognitive metaphor theory

KW - Information systems development

KW - Metaphors

KW - Qualitative case study

KW - Sensemaking

KW - Cognitive metaphor theory

KW - Information systems development

KW - Metaphors

KW - Qualitative case study

KW - Sensemaking

UR - https://sfx-45cbs.hosted.exlibrisgroup.com/45cbs?url_ver=Z39.88-2004&url_ctx_fmt=info:ofi/fmt:kev:mtx:ctx&ctx_enc=info:ofi/enc:UTF-8&ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&rfr_id=info:sid/sfxit.com:azlist&sfx.ignore_date_threshold=1&rft.object_id=954925615054&rft.object_portfolio_id=&svc.holdings=yes&svc.fulltext=yes

U2 - 10.1111/isj.12133

DO - 10.1111/isj.12133

M3 - Journal article

VL - 28

SP - 142

EP - 174

JO - Information Systems Journal

T2 - Information Systems Journal

JF - Information Systems Journal

SN - 1350-1917

IS - 1

ER -