How Would AI Regulation Change Firms’ Behavior? Evidence from Thousands of Managers

Yong Suk Lee, Benjamin Larsen, Michael Webb, Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar

Research output: Working paperResearch

Abstract

We examine the impacts of different proposed AI regulations on managers’ intentions to adopt AI technologies and on their AI-related business strategies. We conduct a randomized online survey experiment on more than a thousand managers in the U.S. We randomly present managers with different proposed AI regulations, and ask them to make decisions about AI adoption, budget allocation, hiring, and other issues. We have four main findings: (1) information about AI regulation generally reduces the rate of adoption of AI technologies. Nonetheless, industry- and agency-specific AI regulation has a smaller impact than general AI regulation. (2) Information about regulation induces firms to think. That is, firms spend more on developing AI strategy and hire more managers. This is at the cost of hiring other workers and training current employees. (3) The impact of information about AI regulation on innovation differs by industry and firm size. AI regulation increases intent to file patents in the healthcare and pharmaceutical sectors, but reduces it in the retail sector. Moreover, AI regulation information reduces AI adoption in small firms and is more likely to reduce their innovative activity. (4) Information about AI regulation increases firms’ perceptions of the importance of safety and transparency issues related to AI.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationStanford, CA
PublisherStanford University
Number of pages60
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2019
SeriesWorking Paper / Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, Stanford University
Number19-031

Keywords

  • Artificial intelligence
  • Regulation
  • Adoption
  • Innovation
  • Strategy
  • Survey experiments

Cite this

Lee, Y. S., Larsen, B., Webb, M., & Cuéllar, M-F. (2019). How Would AI Regulation Change Firms’ Behavior? Evidence from Thousands of Managers. Stanford, CA: Stanford University. Working Paper / Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, Stanford University, No. 19-031
Lee, Yong Suk ; Larsen, Benjamin ; Webb, Michael ; Cuéllar, Mariano-Florentino. / How Would AI Regulation Change Firms’ Behavior? Evidence from Thousands of Managers. Stanford, CA : Stanford University, 2019. (Working Paper / Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, Stanford University; No. 19-031).
@techreport{d1680a60f1ed4b4a9c3574850527c5ea,
title = "How Would AI Regulation Change Firms’ Behavior?: Evidence from Thousands of Managers",
abstract = "We examine the impacts of different proposed AI regulations on managers’ intentions to adopt AI technologies and on their AI-related business strategies. We conduct a randomized online survey experiment on more than a thousand managers in the U.S. We randomly present managers with different proposed AI regulations, and ask them to make decisions about AI adoption, budget allocation, hiring, and other issues. We have four main findings: (1) information about AI regulation generally reduces the rate of adoption of AI technologies. Nonetheless, industry- and agency-specific AI regulation has a smaller impact than general AI regulation. (2) Information about regulation induces firms to think. That is, firms spend more on developing AI strategy and hire more managers. This is at the cost of hiring other workers and training current employees. (3) The impact of information about AI regulation on innovation differs by industry and firm size. AI regulation increases intent to file patents in the healthcare and pharmaceutical sectors, but reduces it in the retail sector. Moreover, AI regulation information reduces AI adoption in small firms and is more likely to reduce their innovative activity. (4) Information about AI regulation increases firms’ perceptions of the importance of safety and transparency issues related to AI.",
keywords = "Artificial intelligence, Regulation, Adoption, Innovation, Strategy, Survey experiments, Artificial intelligence, Regulation, Adoption, Innovation, Strategy, Survey experiments",
author = "Lee, {Yong Suk} and Benjamin Larsen and Michael Webb and Mariano-Florentino Cu{\'e}llar",
year = "2019",
month = "11",
language = "English",
series = "Working Paper / Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, Stanford University",
publisher = "Stanford University",
number = "19-031",
address = "United States",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Stanford University",

}

Lee, YS, Larsen, B, Webb, M & Cuéllar, M-F 2019 'How Would AI Regulation Change Firms’ Behavior? Evidence from Thousands of Managers' Stanford University, Stanford, CA.

How Would AI Regulation Change Firms’ Behavior? Evidence from Thousands of Managers. / Lee, Yong Suk; Larsen, Benjamin; Webb, Michael; Cuéllar, Mariano-Florentino.

Stanford, CA : Stanford University, 2019.

Research output: Working paperResearch

TY - UNPB

T1 - How Would AI Regulation Change Firms’ Behavior?

T2 - Evidence from Thousands of Managers

AU - Lee, Yong Suk

AU - Larsen, Benjamin

AU - Webb, Michael

AU - Cuéllar, Mariano-Florentino

PY - 2019/11

Y1 - 2019/11

N2 - We examine the impacts of different proposed AI regulations on managers’ intentions to adopt AI technologies and on their AI-related business strategies. We conduct a randomized online survey experiment on more than a thousand managers in the U.S. We randomly present managers with different proposed AI regulations, and ask them to make decisions about AI adoption, budget allocation, hiring, and other issues. We have four main findings: (1) information about AI regulation generally reduces the rate of adoption of AI technologies. Nonetheless, industry- and agency-specific AI regulation has a smaller impact than general AI regulation. (2) Information about regulation induces firms to think. That is, firms spend more on developing AI strategy and hire more managers. This is at the cost of hiring other workers and training current employees. (3) The impact of information about AI regulation on innovation differs by industry and firm size. AI regulation increases intent to file patents in the healthcare and pharmaceutical sectors, but reduces it in the retail sector. Moreover, AI regulation information reduces AI adoption in small firms and is more likely to reduce their innovative activity. (4) Information about AI regulation increases firms’ perceptions of the importance of safety and transparency issues related to AI.

AB - We examine the impacts of different proposed AI regulations on managers’ intentions to adopt AI technologies and on their AI-related business strategies. We conduct a randomized online survey experiment on more than a thousand managers in the U.S. We randomly present managers with different proposed AI regulations, and ask them to make decisions about AI adoption, budget allocation, hiring, and other issues. We have four main findings: (1) information about AI regulation generally reduces the rate of adoption of AI technologies. Nonetheless, industry- and agency-specific AI regulation has a smaller impact than general AI regulation. (2) Information about regulation induces firms to think. That is, firms spend more on developing AI strategy and hire more managers. This is at the cost of hiring other workers and training current employees. (3) The impact of information about AI regulation on innovation differs by industry and firm size. AI regulation increases intent to file patents in the healthcare and pharmaceutical sectors, but reduces it in the retail sector. Moreover, AI regulation information reduces AI adoption in small firms and is more likely to reduce their innovative activity. (4) Information about AI regulation increases firms’ perceptions of the importance of safety and transparency issues related to AI.

KW - Artificial intelligence

KW - Regulation

KW - Adoption

KW - Innovation

KW - Strategy

KW - Survey experiments

KW - Artificial intelligence

KW - Regulation

KW - Adoption

KW - Innovation

KW - Strategy

KW - Survey experiments

M3 - Working paper

T3 - Working Paper / Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, Stanford University

BT - How Would AI Regulation Change Firms’ Behavior?

PB - Stanford University

CY - Stanford, CA

ER -

Lee YS, Larsen B, Webb M, Cuéllar M-F. How Would AI Regulation Change Firms’ Behavior? Evidence from Thousands of Managers. Stanford, CA: Stanford University. 2019 Nov.