How Search in Science Impacts on the Value of Inventions at Early and Late Stages in the R&D cycle

Karin Beukel, Finn Valentin, Rasmus Lund Jensen

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    The literatures on innovation and organizational learning have identified search in prior science and technology as critical inputs to industrial R&D. Efforts to distinguish the contributions - separately and combined - of these two search
    orientations are scarce, and quantitative estimates offer contradictory results. The contributions to R&D from science are particularly elusive. To achieve some transparency on these issues we study R&D in biotech drug discovery, where the
    role of science is pervasive and structured into a recurrent sequence of inventions required to build a drug candidate. The patents filed on these inventions offer, through their citations to prior art, a fine-grained view of the role of science along the R&D cycle. Applying a unique text-mining algorithm we categorize a set of 1,058 patens from Scandinavian drug discovery firms into six types of drug-related inventions. Tests confirm a significantly decreasing presence of science vis a vis technology over the R&D cycle. Effects of the composition of search on the value of single inventions show notable differences. In early R&D increasing predominance of search in science detracts from invention value. In late R&D, inventions increase in value when search includes a scientific orientation. Science-based R&D is cognitively heterogeneous and builds value in forms requiring sophisticated R&D management. Our results add to the theoretical understanding of search and the role of science in innovations. They also explain why an aggregate view, as presentedin prior literature, on the value produced by science in R&D leads to contradictory or insignificant findings.
    Original languageEnglish
    Publication date2014
    Number of pages36
    Publication statusPublished - 2014
    EventThe DRUID Society Conference 2014: Entrepreneurship - Organization - Innovation - Copenhagen Business School, Frederiksberg, Denmark
    Duration: 16 Jun 201418 Jun 2014
    Conference number: 36
    http://druid8.sit.aau.dk/druid/registrant/index/login/cid/15

    Conference

    ConferenceThe DRUID Society Conference 2014
    Number36
    LocationCopenhagen Business School
    CountryDenmark
    CityFrederiksberg
    Period16/06/201418/06/2014
    Internet address

    Cite this

    Beukel, K., Valentin, F., & Lund Jensen, R. (2014). How Search in Science Impacts on the Value of Inventions at Early and Late Stages in the R&D cycle. Paper presented at The DRUID Society Conference 2014, Frederiksberg, Denmark.
    Beukel, Karin ; Valentin, Finn ; Lund Jensen, Rasmus. / How Search in Science Impacts on the Value of Inventions at Early and Late Stages in the R&D cycle. Paper presented at The DRUID Society Conference 2014, Frederiksberg, Denmark.36 p.
    @conference{68714df1c36b4e96bbc55d4eba71bccb,
    title = "How Search in Science Impacts on the Value of Inventions at Early and Late Stages in the R&D cycle",
    abstract = "The literatures on innovation and organizational learning have identified search in prior science and technology as critical inputs to industrial R&D. Efforts to distinguish the contributions - separately and combined - of these two searchorientations are scarce, and quantitative estimates offer contradictory results. The contributions to R&D from science are particularly elusive. To achieve some transparency on these issues we study R&D in biotech drug discovery, where therole of science is pervasive and structured into a recurrent sequence of inventions required to build a drug candidate. The patents filed on these inventions offer, through their citations to prior art, a fine-grained view of the role of science along the R&D cycle. Applying a unique text-mining algorithm we categorize a set of 1,058 patens from Scandinavian drug discovery firms into six types of drug-related inventions. Tests confirm a significantly decreasing presence of science vis a vis technology over the R&D cycle. Effects of the composition of search on the value of single inventions show notable differences. In early R&D increasing predominance of search in science detracts from invention value. In late R&D, inventions increase in value when search includes a scientific orientation. Science-based R&D is cognitively heterogeneous and builds value in forms requiring sophisticated R&D management. Our results add to the theoretical understanding of search and the role of science in innovations. They also explain why an aggregate view, as presentedin prior literature, on the value produced by science in R&D leads to contradictory or insignificant findings.",
    author = "Karin Beukel and Finn Valentin and {Lund Jensen}, Rasmus",
    year = "2014",
    language = "English",
    note = "null ; Conference date: 16-06-2014 Through 18-06-2014",
    url = "http://druid8.sit.aau.dk/druid/registrant/index/login/cid/15",

    }

    Beukel, K, Valentin, F & Lund Jensen, R 2014, 'How Search in Science Impacts on the Value of Inventions at Early and Late Stages in the R&D cycle' Paper presented at, Frederiksberg, Denmark, 16/06/2014 - 18/06/2014, .

    How Search in Science Impacts on the Value of Inventions at Early and Late Stages in the R&D cycle. / Beukel, Karin; Valentin, Finn; Lund Jensen, Rasmus.

    2014. Paper presented at The DRUID Society Conference 2014, Frederiksberg, Denmark.

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

    TY - CONF

    T1 - How Search in Science Impacts on the Value of Inventions at Early and Late Stages in the R&D cycle

    AU - Beukel, Karin

    AU - Valentin, Finn

    AU - Lund Jensen, Rasmus

    PY - 2014

    Y1 - 2014

    N2 - The literatures on innovation and organizational learning have identified search in prior science and technology as critical inputs to industrial R&D. Efforts to distinguish the contributions - separately and combined - of these two searchorientations are scarce, and quantitative estimates offer contradictory results. The contributions to R&D from science are particularly elusive. To achieve some transparency on these issues we study R&D in biotech drug discovery, where therole of science is pervasive and structured into a recurrent sequence of inventions required to build a drug candidate. The patents filed on these inventions offer, through their citations to prior art, a fine-grained view of the role of science along the R&D cycle. Applying a unique text-mining algorithm we categorize a set of 1,058 patens from Scandinavian drug discovery firms into six types of drug-related inventions. Tests confirm a significantly decreasing presence of science vis a vis technology over the R&D cycle. Effects of the composition of search on the value of single inventions show notable differences. In early R&D increasing predominance of search in science detracts from invention value. In late R&D, inventions increase in value when search includes a scientific orientation. Science-based R&D is cognitively heterogeneous and builds value in forms requiring sophisticated R&D management. Our results add to the theoretical understanding of search and the role of science in innovations. They also explain why an aggregate view, as presentedin prior literature, on the value produced by science in R&D leads to contradictory or insignificant findings.

    AB - The literatures on innovation and organizational learning have identified search in prior science and technology as critical inputs to industrial R&D. Efforts to distinguish the contributions - separately and combined - of these two searchorientations are scarce, and quantitative estimates offer contradictory results. The contributions to R&D from science are particularly elusive. To achieve some transparency on these issues we study R&D in biotech drug discovery, where therole of science is pervasive and structured into a recurrent sequence of inventions required to build a drug candidate. The patents filed on these inventions offer, through their citations to prior art, a fine-grained view of the role of science along the R&D cycle. Applying a unique text-mining algorithm we categorize a set of 1,058 patens from Scandinavian drug discovery firms into six types of drug-related inventions. Tests confirm a significantly decreasing presence of science vis a vis technology over the R&D cycle. Effects of the composition of search on the value of single inventions show notable differences. In early R&D increasing predominance of search in science detracts from invention value. In late R&D, inventions increase in value when search includes a scientific orientation. Science-based R&D is cognitively heterogeneous and builds value in forms requiring sophisticated R&D management. Our results add to the theoretical understanding of search and the role of science in innovations. They also explain why an aggregate view, as presentedin prior literature, on the value produced by science in R&D leads to contradictory or insignificant findings.

    M3 - Paper

    ER -

    Beukel K, Valentin F, Lund Jensen R. How Search in Science Impacts on the Value of Inventions at Early and Late Stages in the R&D cycle. 2014. Paper presented at The DRUID Society Conference 2014, Frederiksberg, Denmark.