Disclosed Values of Option Based Compensation: Incompetence, Deliberate Underreporting or the Use of Expected Time to Maturity?

Ken L. Bechmann, Toke L. Hjortshøj

Research output: Working paperResearch

8 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

New accounting standards require firms to expense the costs of option-based compensation (OBC), but the associated valuations offer many challenges for firms. Earlier research has documented that firms in the U.S. generally underreport the values of OBC by manipulating the inputs used for valuation purposes. This paper examines the values of OBC disclosed by Danish firms. The results suggest that firms experience some difficulties in valuing OBC, but interestingly, there is no clear evidence of deliberate underreporting. For example, there is no evidence that firms use manipulated values for the Black-Scholes parameters in their valuations. Furthermore, firms determine the expected time to maturity in a way that is generally consistent with the guidelines provided by the new accounting standards.
The findings differ from those of the U.S., but is consistent with the more limited use of OBC and the lower level of attention paid to these values in Denmark. However, the differences can also be due to the fact that several Danish firms do not provide the information required regarding their OBC, which is clearly a very effective way of hiding the true values.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationFrederiksberg
PublisherDanish Center for Accounting and Finance (D-CAF)
Number of pages34
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2007
SeriesD-CAF Working Paper
Number25

Keywords

  • Option-based compensation
  • Option pricing
  • Expected time to maturity

Cite this

Bechmann, K. L., & Hjortshøj, T. L. (2007). Disclosed Values of Option Based Compensation: Incompetence, Deliberate Underreporting or the Use of Expected Time to Maturity? Frederiksberg: Danish Center for Accounting and Finance (D-CAF). D-CAF Working Paper, No. 25
Bechmann, Ken L. ; Hjortshøj, Toke L. / Disclosed Values of Option Based Compensation : Incompetence, Deliberate Underreporting or the Use of Expected Time to Maturity?. Frederiksberg : Danish Center for Accounting and Finance (D-CAF), 2007. (D-CAF Working Paper; No. 25).
@techreport{189fe9c0a3df11dc9bb5000ea68e967b,
title = "Disclosed Values of Option Based Compensation: Incompetence, Deliberate Underreporting or the Use of Expected Time to Maturity?",
abstract = "New accounting standards require firms to expense the costs of option-based compensation (OBC), but the associated valuations offer many challenges for firms. Earlier research has documented that firms in the U.S. generally underreport the values of OBC by manipulating the inputs used for valuation purposes. This paper examines the values of OBC disclosed by Danish firms. The results suggest that firms experience some difficulties in valuing OBC, but interestingly, there is no clear evidence of deliberate underreporting. For example, there is no evidence that firms use manipulated values for the Black-Scholes parameters in their valuations. Furthermore, firms determine the expected time to maturity in a way that is generally consistent with the guidelines provided by the new accounting standards. The findings differ from those of the U.S., but is consistent with the more limited use of OBC and the lower level of attention paid to these values in Denmark. However, the differences can also be due to the fact that several Danish firms do not provide the information required regarding their OBC, which is clearly a very effective way of hiding the true values.",
keywords = "Option-based compensation, Option pricing, Expected time to maturity, Option-based compensation, Option pricing, Expected time to maturity",
author = "Bechmann, {Ken L.} and Hjortsh{\o}j, {Toke L.}",
note = "l{\o}benummer: 077355",
year = "2007",
month = "4",
language = "English",
series = "D-CAF Working Paper",
publisher = "Danish Center for Accounting and Finance (D-CAF)",
number = "25",
address = "Denmark",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Danish Center for Accounting and Finance (D-CAF)",

}

Disclosed Values of Option Based Compensation : Incompetence, Deliberate Underreporting or the Use of Expected Time to Maturity? / Bechmann, Ken L.; Hjortshøj, Toke L.

Frederiksberg : Danish Center for Accounting and Finance (D-CAF), 2007.

Research output: Working paperResearch

TY - UNPB

T1 - Disclosed Values of Option Based Compensation

T2 - Incompetence, Deliberate Underreporting or the Use of Expected Time to Maturity?

AU - Bechmann, Ken L.

AU - Hjortshøj, Toke L.

N1 - løbenummer: 077355

PY - 2007/4

Y1 - 2007/4

N2 - New accounting standards require firms to expense the costs of option-based compensation (OBC), but the associated valuations offer many challenges for firms. Earlier research has documented that firms in the U.S. generally underreport the values of OBC by manipulating the inputs used for valuation purposes. This paper examines the values of OBC disclosed by Danish firms. The results suggest that firms experience some difficulties in valuing OBC, but interestingly, there is no clear evidence of deliberate underreporting. For example, there is no evidence that firms use manipulated values for the Black-Scholes parameters in their valuations. Furthermore, firms determine the expected time to maturity in a way that is generally consistent with the guidelines provided by the new accounting standards. The findings differ from those of the U.S., but is consistent with the more limited use of OBC and the lower level of attention paid to these values in Denmark. However, the differences can also be due to the fact that several Danish firms do not provide the information required regarding their OBC, which is clearly a very effective way of hiding the true values.

AB - New accounting standards require firms to expense the costs of option-based compensation (OBC), but the associated valuations offer many challenges for firms. Earlier research has documented that firms in the U.S. generally underreport the values of OBC by manipulating the inputs used for valuation purposes. This paper examines the values of OBC disclosed by Danish firms. The results suggest that firms experience some difficulties in valuing OBC, but interestingly, there is no clear evidence of deliberate underreporting. For example, there is no evidence that firms use manipulated values for the Black-Scholes parameters in their valuations. Furthermore, firms determine the expected time to maturity in a way that is generally consistent with the guidelines provided by the new accounting standards. The findings differ from those of the U.S., but is consistent with the more limited use of OBC and the lower level of attention paid to these values in Denmark. However, the differences can also be due to the fact that several Danish firms do not provide the information required regarding their OBC, which is clearly a very effective way of hiding the true values.

KW - Option-based compensation

KW - Option pricing

KW - Expected time to maturity

KW - Option-based compensation

KW - Option pricing

KW - Expected time to maturity

M3 - Working paper

T3 - D-CAF Working Paper

BT - Disclosed Values of Option Based Compensation

PB - Danish Center for Accounting and Finance (D-CAF)

CY - Frederiksberg

ER -

Bechmann KL, Hjortshøj TL. Disclosed Values of Option Based Compensation: Incompetence, Deliberate Underreporting or the Use of Expected Time to Maturity? Frederiksberg: Danish Center for Accounting and Finance (D-CAF). 2007 Apr.