Did ECB Liquidity Injections Help the Real Economy in Europe?

Stine Louise Daetz, Marti G. Subrahmanyam, Dragon Y. Tang, Sarah Q. Wang

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

In an effort to boost the Eurozone economy, the European Central Bank (ECB) launched a plethora of monetary interventions, of which the series of Longer-Term Refinancing Operations (LTROs) was among the most significant. An important measure of the efficacy of these LTRO programs is their impact on non-financial corporations. In this paper, we show that non-financial firms in the Eurozone indeed ended up with more cash as a consequence of the ECB liquidity injections. However, such an increase in cash holdings was not necessarily employed in a productive manner, but as a form of "carry trade", since corporations did not make significant real investments, as a consequence. Rather, firms seem to have taken advantage of the easy credit from both private bank loans and public corporate bonds to hoard the cash (some of which may have been in the form of Treasury bonds of Eurozone periphery countries, carrying a high yield). Also, the cash hoarding effect is stronger for firms situated in the periphery countries. Overall, we conclude that the ECB's unconventional monetary policies have not necessarily helped the real economy in the Eurozone at a time when aggregate demand is weak, as evidenced by weak corporate investments.
Original languageEnglish
Publication date2016
Number of pages70
Publication statusPublished - 2016
EventThe 43rd European Finance Association Annual Meeting (EFA 2016) - BI Norwegian Business School, Oslo, Norway
Duration: 17 Aug 201620 Aug 2016
Conference number: 43
http://www.efa2016.org/

Conference

ConferenceThe 43rd European Finance Association Annual Meeting (EFA 2016)
Number43
LocationBI Norwegian Business School
CountryNorway
CityOslo
Period17/08/201620/08/2016
Internet address

Keywords

  • Monetary policy interventions
  • ECB
  • Liquidity
  • Cash holdings
  • Real economy

Cite this

Daetz, S. L., Subrahmanyam, M. G., Tang, D. Y., & Wang, S. Q. (2016). Did ECB Liquidity Injections Help the Real Economy in Europe?. Paper presented at The 43rd European Finance Association Annual Meeting (EFA 2016), Oslo, Norway.
Daetz, Stine Louise ; Subrahmanyam, Marti G. ; Tang, Dragon Y. ; Wang, Sarah Q. / Did ECB Liquidity Injections Help the Real Economy in Europe?. Paper presented at The 43rd European Finance Association Annual Meeting (EFA 2016), Oslo, Norway.70 p.
@conference{4e1d0a9cac4449b396eaca73dd4756c3,
title = "Did ECB Liquidity Injections Help the Real Economy in Europe?",
abstract = "In an effort to boost the Eurozone economy, the European Central Bank (ECB) launched a plethora of monetary interventions, of which the series of Longer-Term Refinancing Operations (LTROs) was among the most significant. An important measure of the efficacy of these LTRO programs is their impact on non-financial corporations. In this paper, we show that non-financial firms in the Eurozone indeed ended up with more cash as a consequence of the ECB liquidity injections. However, such an increase in cash holdings was not necessarily employed in a productive manner, but as a form of {"}carry trade{"}, since corporations did not make significant real investments, as a consequence. Rather, firms seem to have taken advantage of the easy credit from both private bank loans and public corporate bonds to hoard the cash (some of which may have been in the form of Treasury bonds of Eurozone periphery countries, carrying a high yield). Also, the cash hoarding effect is stronger for firms situated in the periphery countries. Overall, we conclude that the ECB's unconventional monetary policies have not necessarily helped the real economy in the Eurozone at a time when aggregate demand is weak, as evidenced by weak corporate investments.",
keywords = "Monetary policy interventions, ECB, Liquidity, Cash holdings, Real economy, Monetary policy interventions, ECB, Liquidity, Cash holdings, Real economy",
author = "Daetz, {Stine Louise} and Subrahmanyam, {Marti G.} and Tang, {Dragon Y.} and Wang, {Sarah Q.}",
year = "2016",
language = "English",
note = "null ; Conference date: 17-08-2016 Through 20-08-2016",
url = "http://www.efa2016.org/",

}

Daetz, SL, Subrahmanyam, MG, Tang, DY & Wang, SQ 2016, 'Did ECB Liquidity Injections Help the Real Economy in Europe?' Paper presented at, Oslo, Norway, 17/08/2016 - 20/08/2016, .

Did ECB Liquidity Injections Help the Real Economy in Europe? / Daetz, Stine Louise ; Subrahmanyam, Marti G. ; Tang, Dragon Y.; Wang, Sarah Q.

2016. Paper presented at The 43rd European Finance Association Annual Meeting (EFA 2016), Oslo, Norway.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

TY - CONF

T1 - Did ECB Liquidity Injections Help the Real Economy in Europe?

AU - Daetz, Stine Louise

AU - Subrahmanyam, Marti G.

AU - Tang, Dragon Y.

AU - Wang, Sarah Q.

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - In an effort to boost the Eurozone economy, the European Central Bank (ECB) launched a plethora of monetary interventions, of which the series of Longer-Term Refinancing Operations (LTROs) was among the most significant. An important measure of the efficacy of these LTRO programs is their impact on non-financial corporations. In this paper, we show that non-financial firms in the Eurozone indeed ended up with more cash as a consequence of the ECB liquidity injections. However, such an increase in cash holdings was not necessarily employed in a productive manner, but as a form of "carry trade", since corporations did not make significant real investments, as a consequence. Rather, firms seem to have taken advantage of the easy credit from both private bank loans and public corporate bonds to hoard the cash (some of which may have been in the form of Treasury bonds of Eurozone periphery countries, carrying a high yield). Also, the cash hoarding effect is stronger for firms situated in the periphery countries. Overall, we conclude that the ECB's unconventional monetary policies have not necessarily helped the real economy in the Eurozone at a time when aggregate demand is weak, as evidenced by weak corporate investments.

AB - In an effort to boost the Eurozone economy, the European Central Bank (ECB) launched a plethora of monetary interventions, of which the series of Longer-Term Refinancing Operations (LTROs) was among the most significant. An important measure of the efficacy of these LTRO programs is their impact on non-financial corporations. In this paper, we show that non-financial firms in the Eurozone indeed ended up with more cash as a consequence of the ECB liquidity injections. However, such an increase in cash holdings was not necessarily employed in a productive manner, but as a form of "carry trade", since corporations did not make significant real investments, as a consequence. Rather, firms seem to have taken advantage of the easy credit from both private bank loans and public corporate bonds to hoard the cash (some of which may have been in the form of Treasury bonds of Eurozone periphery countries, carrying a high yield). Also, the cash hoarding effect is stronger for firms situated in the periphery countries. Overall, we conclude that the ECB's unconventional monetary policies have not necessarily helped the real economy in the Eurozone at a time when aggregate demand is weak, as evidenced by weak corporate investments.

KW - Monetary policy interventions

KW - ECB

KW - Liquidity

KW - Cash holdings

KW - Real economy

KW - Monetary policy interventions

KW - ECB

KW - Liquidity

KW - Cash holdings

KW - Real economy

M3 - Paper

ER -

Daetz SL, Subrahmanyam MG, Tang DY, Wang SQ. Did ECB Liquidity Injections Help the Real Economy in Europe?. 2016. Paper presented at The 43rd European Finance Association Annual Meeting (EFA 2016), Oslo, Norway.