Abstract
How come the biofuel trajectory continues to be promoted worldwide despite serious concerns about its potentially adverse social and environmental effects? Most explanations rightly consider incumbent economic interests in the global value chains as the key driver. This, however, does not explain in details how a
controversial technology manifests itself in specific contexts.
This paper describes a case study on public debates on biofuels in Denmark. Particular emphasis is placed on how epistemic and political claims are coupled in this debate. It shows how two competing scientific perspectives on biofuels map onto the policy debates through articulation by two competing issue coalitions. One is a ‘bottom-up’ perspective originating in biochemistry,
which is favoured by biofuel optimists. The other is a ‘top-down’ perspective originating in life cycle analysis, which is favoured by biofuel sceptics. While epistemic perspectives do not determine policy frames exclusively, clear affinities between knowledge production in different scientific disciplines and
policy positions can be identified in both camps in the debates on biofuels.
controversial technology manifests itself in specific contexts.
This paper describes a case study on public debates on biofuels in Denmark. Particular emphasis is placed on how epistemic and political claims are coupled in this debate. It shows how two competing scientific perspectives on biofuels map onto the policy debates through articulation by two competing issue coalitions. One is a ‘bottom-up’ perspective originating in biochemistry,
which is favoured by biofuel optimists. The other is a ‘top-down’ perspective originating in life cycle analysis, which is favoured by biofuel sceptics. While epistemic perspectives do not determine policy frames exclusively, clear affinities between knowledge production in different scientific disciplines and
policy positions can be identified in both camps in the debates on biofuels.
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Publication date | 2012 |
| Publication status | Published - 2012 |
| Event | The 4S/EASST Joint Conference 2012: Design and displacement: Social Studies of Science and Technology - Copenhagen Business School, Frederiksberg, Denmark Duration: 17 Oct 2012 → 20 Oct 2012 Conference number: 2012 https://sf.cbs.dk/4s_easst/final_conference_program_ready |
Conference
| Conference | The 4S/EASST Joint Conference 2012 |
|---|---|
| Number | 2012 |
| Location | Copenhagen Business School |
| Country/Territory | Denmark |
| City | Frederiksberg |
| Period | 17/10/2012 → 20/10/2012 |
| Internet address |