Benevolent Discrimination: Explaining How Human Resources Professionals Can Be Blind to the Harm of Diversity Initiatives

Laurence Romani, Lotte Holck, Annette Risberg

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

59 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This article contributes to critical diversity management studies by exploring how human resources professionals do not see that the diversity measures they initiate can contribute to the reproduction of inequalities. We argue that framing such practices as benevolent obscures the fact that they are discriminatory acts. Drawing on the concept of benevolent discrimination, we conceptualise it along three dimensions: (1) a well-intended effort to address discrimination within (2) a social relationship that constructs the others as inferior and in need of help, which is granted with (3) the expectation that they will accommodate into the existing hierarchical order. Benevolent discrimination is a subtle and structural form of discrimination that is difficult to see for those performing it, because it frames their action as positive, in solidarity with the (inferior) other who is helped, and within a hierarchical order that is taken for granted. We develop the concept of benevolent discrimination building on an in-depth qualitative case study of a Swedish organisation that is believed to be exemplary in its engagement in diversity management initiatives. The organisation is however swayed by an inequality regime based on the intersection of class and ethnicity. We argue that it is precisely because human resources professionals frame their actions as acts of benevolence that they cannot see how they take part in organisational discrimination.
Original languageEnglish
JournalOrganization
Volume26
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)371-390
Number of pages20
ISSN1350-5084
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2019

Bibliographical note

Published online November 22, 2018

Keywords

  • Accommodation
  • Benevolent discrimination
  • Class
  • Diversity management
  • Ethnicity
  • Gratitude
  • Inequality regime
  • Racial order
  • Solidarity

Cite this

@article{f7ad6d68a7ab45f29975e38105ec0b46,
title = "Benevolent Discrimination: Explaining How Human Resources Professionals Can Be Blind to the Harm of Diversity Initiatives",
abstract = "This article contributes to critical diversity management studies by exploring how human resources professionals do not see that the diversity measures they initiate can contribute to the reproduction of inequalities. We argue that framing such practices as benevolent obscures the fact that they are discriminatory acts. Drawing on the concept of benevolent discrimination, we conceptualise it along three dimensions: (1) a well-intended effort to address discrimination within (2) a social relationship that constructs the others as inferior and in need of help, which is granted with (3) the expectation that they will accommodate into the existing hierarchical order. Benevolent discrimination is a subtle and structural form of discrimination that is difficult to see for those performing it, because it frames their action as positive, in solidarity with the (inferior) other who is helped, and within a hierarchical order that is taken for granted. We develop the concept of benevolent discrimination building on an in-depth qualitative case study of a Swedish organisation that is believed to be exemplary in its engagement in diversity management initiatives. The organisation is however swayed by an inequality regime based on the intersection of class and ethnicity. We argue that it is precisely because human resources professionals frame their actions as acts of benevolence that they cannot see how they take part in organisational discrimination.",
keywords = "Accommodation, Benevolent discrimination, Class, Diversity management, Ethnicity, Gratitude, Inequality regime, Racial order, Solidarity, Accommodation, Benevolent discrimination, Class, Diversity management, Ethnicity, Gratitude, Inequality regime, Racial order, Solidarity",
author = "Laurence Romani and Lotte Holck and Annette Risberg",
note = "Published online November 22, 2018",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1177/1350508418812585",
language = "English",
volume = "26",
pages = "371--390",
journal = "Organization",
issn = "1350-5084",
publisher = "Sage Publications Ltd.",
number = "3",

}

Benevolent Discrimination : Explaining How Human Resources Professionals Can Be Blind to the Harm of Diversity Initiatives. / Romani, Laurence; Holck, Lotte; Risberg, Annette.

In: Organization, Vol. 26, No. 3, 05.2019, p. 371-390.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Benevolent Discrimination

T2 - Explaining How Human Resources Professionals Can Be Blind to the Harm of Diversity Initiatives

AU - Romani, Laurence

AU - Holck, Lotte

AU - Risberg, Annette

N1 - Published online November 22, 2018

PY - 2019/5

Y1 - 2019/5

N2 - This article contributes to critical diversity management studies by exploring how human resources professionals do not see that the diversity measures they initiate can contribute to the reproduction of inequalities. We argue that framing such practices as benevolent obscures the fact that they are discriminatory acts. Drawing on the concept of benevolent discrimination, we conceptualise it along three dimensions: (1) a well-intended effort to address discrimination within (2) a social relationship that constructs the others as inferior and in need of help, which is granted with (3) the expectation that they will accommodate into the existing hierarchical order. Benevolent discrimination is a subtle and structural form of discrimination that is difficult to see for those performing it, because it frames their action as positive, in solidarity with the (inferior) other who is helped, and within a hierarchical order that is taken for granted. We develop the concept of benevolent discrimination building on an in-depth qualitative case study of a Swedish organisation that is believed to be exemplary in its engagement in diversity management initiatives. The organisation is however swayed by an inequality regime based on the intersection of class and ethnicity. We argue that it is precisely because human resources professionals frame their actions as acts of benevolence that they cannot see how they take part in organisational discrimination.

AB - This article contributes to critical diversity management studies by exploring how human resources professionals do not see that the diversity measures they initiate can contribute to the reproduction of inequalities. We argue that framing such practices as benevolent obscures the fact that they are discriminatory acts. Drawing on the concept of benevolent discrimination, we conceptualise it along three dimensions: (1) a well-intended effort to address discrimination within (2) a social relationship that constructs the others as inferior and in need of help, which is granted with (3) the expectation that they will accommodate into the existing hierarchical order. Benevolent discrimination is a subtle and structural form of discrimination that is difficult to see for those performing it, because it frames their action as positive, in solidarity with the (inferior) other who is helped, and within a hierarchical order that is taken for granted. We develop the concept of benevolent discrimination building on an in-depth qualitative case study of a Swedish organisation that is believed to be exemplary in its engagement in diversity management initiatives. The organisation is however swayed by an inequality regime based on the intersection of class and ethnicity. We argue that it is precisely because human resources professionals frame their actions as acts of benevolence that they cannot see how they take part in organisational discrimination.

KW - Accommodation

KW - Benevolent discrimination

KW - Class

KW - Diversity management

KW - Ethnicity

KW - Gratitude

KW - Inequality regime

KW - Racial order

KW - Solidarity

KW - Accommodation

KW - Benevolent discrimination

KW - Class

KW - Diversity management

KW - Ethnicity

KW - Gratitude

KW - Inequality regime

KW - Racial order

KW - Solidarity

UR - https://sfx-45cbs.hosted.exlibrisgroup.com/45cbs?url_ver=Z39.88-2004&url_ctx_fmt=info:ofi/fmt:kev:mtx:ctx&ctx_enc=info:ofi/enc:UTF-8&ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&rfr_id=info:sid/sfxit.com:azlist&sfx.ignore_date_threshold=1&rft.object_id=954925616074&rft.object_portfolio_id=&svc.holdings=yes&svc.fulltext=yes

U2 - 10.1177/1350508418812585

DO - 10.1177/1350508418812585

M3 - Journal article

VL - 26

SP - 371

EP - 390

JO - Organization

JF - Organization

SN - 1350-5084

IS - 3

ER -