Are the Best Broths Really Made in the Oldest Pots? Promises and Limits of the Resurrection of the Concept of Empire in EU Studies

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearch

    Abstract

    After the wave of decolonization, the USSR was the only contemporary political system to be called an empire. When it collapsed, scholars started using the notion of empire in the context of the USA. Now, some EU scholars use the notion of empire in the European context too. Interestingly, the EU offers the first contemporary context of use of this notion in a mainly normatively neutral way. Empire is ‘simply’ used to describe and analyze recent trends in the integration process, which nonetheless raises questions. Has this political concept been dug out of Europe’s history because the integration process is taking a different path? Is it because the explanatory potential of standard theories of integration has been exhausted while the so-called ‘new theories of integration’ are disappointing because they aren’t really theories of integration? But can the concept of empire provide better explanations than the two theories which have dominated the scholarly debate since the creation of the EC/EU and than the new theories, which don't really succeed in challenging the old ones? What exactly is the added value of this concept? Should we bother using it at all? This paper presents a critical analysis of the use of the concept of empire in publications on the EU. It explores the potential as well as the limits of this concept in terms of theorization, of methodological implications and of explanatory potential.
    Original languageEnglish
    Publication date2014
    Number of pages15
    Publication statusPublished - 2014
    Event21st International Conference of Europeanists. 2014: Resurrections - Omni Shoreham Hotel, Washington, D.C., United States
    Duration: 14 Mar 201416 Mar 2014
    Conference number: 21
    http://councilforeuropeanstudies.org/conferences/past-conferences/11-meetings-and-conferences/184-2014-conference

    Conference

    Conference21st International Conference of Europeanists. 2014
    Number21
    LocationOmni Shoreham Hotel
    CountryUnited States
    CityWashington, D.C.
    Period14/03/201416/03/2014
    Internet address

    Bibliographical note

    CBS Library does not have access to the material

    Cite this

    Gravier, M. (2014). Are the Best Broths Really Made in the Oldest Pots? Promises and Limits of the Resurrection of the Concept of Empire in EU Studies. Paper presented at 21st International Conference of Europeanists. 2014, Washington, D.C., United States.
    Gravier, Magali. / Are the Best Broths Really Made in the Oldest Pots? Promises and Limits of the Resurrection of the Concept of Empire in EU Studies. Paper presented at 21st International Conference of Europeanists. 2014, Washington, D.C., United States.15 p.
    @conference{43b54c89e23f48b2aa0d1622d2d49361,
    title = "Are the Best Broths Really Made in the Oldest Pots?: Promises and Limits of the Resurrection of the Concept of Empire in EU Studies",
    abstract = "After the wave of decolonization, the USSR was the only contemporary political system to be called an empire. When it collapsed, scholars started using the notion of empire in the context of the USA. Now, some EU scholars use the notion of empire in the European context too. Interestingly, the EU offers the first contemporary context of use of this notion in a mainly normatively neutral way. Empire is ‘simply’ used to describe and analyze recent trends in the integration process, which nonetheless raises questions. Has this political concept been dug out of Europe’s history because the integration process is taking a different path? Is it because the explanatory potential of standard theories of integration has been exhausted while the so-called ‘new theories of integration’ are disappointing because they aren’t really theories of integration? But can the concept of empire provide better explanations than the two theories which have dominated the scholarly debate since the creation of the EC/EU and than the new theories, which don't really succeed in challenging the old ones? What exactly is the added value of this concept? Should we bother using it at all? This paper presents a critical analysis of the use of the concept of empire in publications on the EU. It explores the potential as well as the limits of this concept in terms of theorization, of methodological implications and of explanatory potential.",
    author = "Magali Gravier",
    note = "CBS Library does not have access to the material; null ; Conference date: 14-03-2014 Through 16-03-2014",
    year = "2014",
    language = "English",
    url = "http://councilforeuropeanstudies.org/conferences/past-conferences/11-meetings-and-conferences/184-2014-conference",

    }

    Are the Best Broths Really Made in the Oldest Pots? Promises and Limits of the Resurrection of the Concept of Empire in EU Studies. / Gravier, Magali.

    2014. Paper presented at 21st International Conference of Europeanists. 2014, Washington, D.C., United States.

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearch

    TY - CONF

    T1 - Are the Best Broths Really Made in the Oldest Pots?

    T2 - Promises and Limits of the Resurrection of the Concept of Empire in EU Studies

    AU - Gravier, Magali

    N1 - CBS Library does not have access to the material

    PY - 2014

    Y1 - 2014

    N2 - After the wave of decolonization, the USSR was the only contemporary political system to be called an empire. When it collapsed, scholars started using the notion of empire in the context of the USA. Now, some EU scholars use the notion of empire in the European context too. Interestingly, the EU offers the first contemporary context of use of this notion in a mainly normatively neutral way. Empire is ‘simply’ used to describe and analyze recent trends in the integration process, which nonetheless raises questions. Has this political concept been dug out of Europe’s history because the integration process is taking a different path? Is it because the explanatory potential of standard theories of integration has been exhausted while the so-called ‘new theories of integration’ are disappointing because they aren’t really theories of integration? But can the concept of empire provide better explanations than the two theories which have dominated the scholarly debate since the creation of the EC/EU and than the new theories, which don't really succeed in challenging the old ones? What exactly is the added value of this concept? Should we bother using it at all? This paper presents a critical analysis of the use of the concept of empire in publications on the EU. It explores the potential as well as the limits of this concept in terms of theorization, of methodological implications and of explanatory potential.

    AB - After the wave of decolonization, the USSR was the only contemporary political system to be called an empire. When it collapsed, scholars started using the notion of empire in the context of the USA. Now, some EU scholars use the notion of empire in the European context too. Interestingly, the EU offers the first contemporary context of use of this notion in a mainly normatively neutral way. Empire is ‘simply’ used to describe and analyze recent trends in the integration process, which nonetheless raises questions. Has this political concept been dug out of Europe’s history because the integration process is taking a different path? Is it because the explanatory potential of standard theories of integration has been exhausted while the so-called ‘new theories of integration’ are disappointing because they aren’t really theories of integration? But can the concept of empire provide better explanations than the two theories which have dominated the scholarly debate since the creation of the EC/EU and than the new theories, which don't really succeed in challenging the old ones? What exactly is the added value of this concept? Should we bother using it at all? This paper presents a critical analysis of the use of the concept of empire in publications on the EU. It explores the potential as well as the limits of this concept in terms of theorization, of methodological implications and of explanatory potential.

    M3 - Paper

    ER -

    Gravier M. Are the Best Broths Really Made in the Oldest Pots? Promises and Limits of the Resurrection of the Concept of Empire in EU Studies. 2014. Paper presented at 21st International Conference of Europeanists. 2014, Washington, D.C., United States.