Accident Aversion: An Experiment

Alice Guerra, Francesco Parisi

Research output: Working paperResearch

Abstract

Tort models predict a symmetry in the behavior of tortfeasors and victims when respectively faced by strict liability or no liability. This paper relies upon the standard accident model and uses an original experimental design to investigate whether the prediction of the tort model holds in actual accident situations. Precisely, we study how individual care choices are affected by the role played by the subject in an accident — as a prospective tortfeasor facing strict liability or as a prospective victim facing the risk of uncompensated loss. Contrary to the theoretical predictions, the results of our experiment show that prospective tortfeasors and victims undertake different investments in precautions when faced with identical financial risks. Victims are more likely to invest in precautions than tortfeasors. We discuss the tort policy implications of our behavioral findings and their practical relevance for accident prevention.
Tort models predict a symmetry in the behavior of tortfeasors and victims when respectively faced by strict liability or no liability. This paper relies upon the standard accident model and uses an original experimental design to investigate whether the prediction of the tort model holds in actual accident situations. Precisely, we study how individual care choices are affected by the role played by the subject in an accident — as a prospective tortfeasor facing strict liability or as a prospective victim facing the risk of uncompensated loss. Contrary to the theoretical predictions, the results of our experiment show that prospective tortfeasors and victims undertake different investments in precautions when faced with identical financial risks. Victims are more likely to invest in precautions than tortfeasors. We discuss the tort policy implications of our behavioral findings and their practical relevance for accident prevention.
LanguageEnglish
PublisherSSRN: Social Science Research Network
Number of pages42
DOIs
StatePublished - 2018
SeriesMinnesota Law School Working Papers
Number04
Volume18

Cite this

Guerra, A., & Parisi, F. (2018). Accident Aversion: An Experiment. SSRN: Social Science Research Network. Minnesota Law School Working Papers, No. 04, Vol.. 18, DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.3133168
Guerra, Alice ; Parisi, Francesco. / Accident Aversion : An Experiment. SSRN: Social Science Research Network, 2018. (Minnesota Law School Working Papers; No. 04, ???volume??? 18).
@techreport{bfe6f16b4d0f473f9f183565f9a6d880,
title = "Accident Aversion: An Experiment",
abstract = "Tort models predict a symmetry in the behavior of tortfeasors and victims when respectively faced by strict liability or no liability. This paper relies upon the standard accident model and uses an original experimental design to investigate whether the prediction of the tort model holds in actual accident situations. Precisely, we study how individual care choices are affected by the role played by the subject in an accident — as a prospective tortfeasor facing strict liability or as a prospective victim facing the risk of uncompensated loss. Contrary to the theoretical predictions, the results of our experiment show that prospective tortfeasors and victims undertake different investments in precautions when faced with identical financial risks. Victims are more likely to invest in precautions than tortfeasors. We discuss the tort policy implications of our behavioral findings and their practical relevance for accident prevention.",
author = "Alice Guerra and Francesco Parisi",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.2139/ssrn.3133168",
language = "English",
publisher = "SSRN: Social Science Research Network",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "SSRN: Social Science Research Network",

}

Guerra, A & Parisi, F 2018 'Accident Aversion: An Experiment' SSRN: Social Science Research Network. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.3133168

Accident Aversion : An Experiment. / Guerra, Alice; Parisi, Francesco.

SSRN: Social Science Research Network, 2018.

Research output: Working paperResearch

TY - UNPB

T1 - Accident Aversion

T2 - An Experiment

AU - Guerra,Alice

AU - Parisi,Francesco

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Tort models predict a symmetry in the behavior of tortfeasors and victims when respectively faced by strict liability or no liability. This paper relies upon the standard accident model and uses an original experimental design to investigate whether the prediction of the tort model holds in actual accident situations. Precisely, we study how individual care choices are affected by the role played by the subject in an accident — as a prospective tortfeasor facing strict liability or as a prospective victim facing the risk of uncompensated loss. Contrary to the theoretical predictions, the results of our experiment show that prospective tortfeasors and victims undertake different investments in precautions when faced with identical financial risks. Victims are more likely to invest in precautions than tortfeasors. We discuss the tort policy implications of our behavioral findings and their practical relevance for accident prevention.

AB - Tort models predict a symmetry in the behavior of tortfeasors and victims when respectively faced by strict liability or no liability. This paper relies upon the standard accident model and uses an original experimental design to investigate whether the prediction of the tort model holds in actual accident situations. Precisely, we study how individual care choices are affected by the role played by the subject in an accident — as a prospective tortfeasor facing strict liability or as a prospective victim facing the risk of uncompensated loss. Contrary to the theoretical predictions, the results of our experiment show that prospective tortfeasors and victims undertake different investments in precautions when faced with identical financial risks. Victims are more likely to invest in precautions than tortfeasors. We discuss the tort policy implications of our behavioral findings and their practical relevance for accident prevention.

U2 - 10.2139/ssrn.3133168

DO - 10.2139/ssrn.3133168

M3 - Working paper

BT - Accident Aversion

PB - SSRN: Social Science Research Network

ER -

Guerra A, Parisi F. Accident Aversion: An Experiment. SSRN: Social Science Research Network. 2018. Available from, DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.3133168