A Guide to the Systematic Literature Review Methodology in Supply Chain Management: Recommendations for Authors, Reviewers and Editors

Christian F. Durach, Andreas Wieland, Joakim Kembro

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Literature reviews lay the foundation for almost every academic research project, and sometimes are a scholarly contribution in its own right. To increase rigor and credibility the findings have to be valid and reliable just as in any other type of research. This paper summarizes recent methodological developments in the application systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. It analyzes what approaches researchers in supply chain management have taken to follow the requirements of a systematic review, identifies issues in the approaches and provides authors, reviewers and editors with suggestions to better craft, disseminate, evaluate and select systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. This paper applies a systematic literature review approach to identify and analyze 31 articles published in core supply chain journals. It is the first research to map these developments, since three seminal methodology papers on systematic reviews in management research have been published between 2003-2009. This research shows that there is still a need for more transparency in the approaches taken. Systematic literature reviews have a high potential to advance the field, but a rigorous and transparent application is needed and should be requested by reviewers and editors.
Literature reviews lay the foundation for almost every academic research project, and sometimes are a scholarly contribution in its own right. To increase rigor and credibility the findings have to be valid and reliable just as in any other type of research. This paper summarizes recent methodological developments in the application systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. It analyzes what approaches researchers in supply chain management have taken to follow the requirements of a systematic review, identifies issues in the approaches and provides authors, reviewers and editors with suggestions to better craft, disseminate, evaluate and select systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. This paper applies a systematic literature review approach to identify and analyze 31 articles published in core supply chain journals. It is the first research to map these developments, since three seminal methodology papers on systematic reviews in management research have been published between 2003-2009. This research shows that there is still a need for more transparency in the approaches taken. Systematic literature reviews have a high potential to advance the field, but a rigorous and transparent application is needed and should be requested by reviewers and editors.

Seminar

SeminarThe 9th European Research Seminar on Logistics and SCM. ERS 2014
Number9
LocationWHU – Otto Beisheim School of Management
CountryGermany
CityDüsseldorf
Period28/04/201429/04/2014
Internet address

Bibliographical note

CBS Library does not have access to the material

Keywords

    Cite this

    Durach, C. F., Wieland, A., & Kembro, J. (2014). A Guide to the Systematic Literature Review Methodology in Supply Chain Management: Recommendations for Authors, Reviewers and Editors. Paper presented at The 9th European Research Seminar on Logistics and SCM. ERS 2014, Düsseldorf, Germany.
    Durach, Christian F. ; Wieland, Andreas ; Kembro, Joakim. / A Guide to the Systematic Literature Review Methodology in Supply Chain Management : Recommendations for Authors, Reviewers and Editors. Paper presented at The 9th European Research Seminar on Logistics and SCM. ERS 2014, Düsseldorf, Germany.14 p.
    @conference{6b4a568d60a148cd9eb6892a41221c85,
    title = "A Guide to the Systematic Literature Review Methodology in Supply Chain Management: Recommendations for Authors, Reviewers and Editors",
    abstract = "Literature reviews lay the foundation for almost every academic research project, and sometimes are a scholarly contribution in its own right. To increase rigor and credibility the findings have to be valid and reliable just as in any other type of research. This paper summarizes recent methodological developments in the application systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. It analyzes what approaches researchers in supply chain management have taken to follow the requirements of a systematic review, identifies issues in the approaches and provides authors, reviewers and editors with suggestions to better craft, disseminate, evaluate and select systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. This paper applies a systematic literature review approach to identify and analyze 31 articles published in core supply chain journals. It is the first research to map these developments, since three seminal methodology papers on systematic reviews in management research have been published between 2003-2009. This research shows that there is still a need for more transparency in the approaches taken. Systematic literature reviews have a high potential to advance the field, but a rigorous and transparent application is needed and should be requested by reviewers and editors.",
    keywords = "Systematic literature review, Methodology, Supply chain management",
    author = "Durach, {Christian F.} and Andreas Wieland and Joakim Kembro",
    note = "CBS Library does not have access to the material; null ; Conference date: 28-04-2014 Through 29-04-2014",
    year = "2014",
    language = "English",
    url = "http://www.whu.edu/ERS",

    }

    Durach, CF, Wieland, A & Kembro, J 2014, 'A Guide to the Systematic Literature Review Methodology in Supply Chain Management: Recommendations for Authors, Reviewers and Editors' Paper presented at, Düsseldorf, Germany, 28/04/2014 - 29/04/2014, .

    A Guide to the Systematic Literature Review Methodology in Supply Chain Management : Recommendations for Authors, Reviewers and Editors. / Durach, Christian F.; Wieland, Andreas; Kembro, Joakim.

    2014. Paper presented at The 9th European Research Seminar on Logistics and SCM. ERS 2014, Düsseldorf, Germany.

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

    TY - CONF

    T1 - A Guide to the Systematic Literature Review Methodology in Supply Chain Management

    T2 - Recommendations for Authors, Reviewers and Editors

    AU - Durach,Christian F.

    AU - Wieland,Andreas

    AU - Kembro,Joakim

    N1 - CBS Library does not have access to the material

    PY - 2014

    Y1 - 2014

    N2 - Literature reviews lay the foundation for almost every academic research project, and sometimes are a scholarly contribution in its own right. To increase rigor and credibility the findings have to be valid and reliable just as in any other type of research. This paper summarizes recent methodological developments in the application systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. It analyzes what approaches researchers in supply chain management have taken to follow the requirements of a systematic review, identifies issues in the approaches and provides authors, reviewers and editors with suggestions to better craft, disseminate, evaluate and select systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. This paper applies a systematic literature review approach to identify and analyze 31 articles published in core supply chain journals. It is the first research to map these developments, since three seminal methodology papers on systematic reviews in management research have been published between 2003-2009. This research shows that there is still a need for more transparency in the approaches taken. Systematic literature reviews have a high potential to advance the field, but a rigorous and transparent application is needed and should be requested by reviewers and editors.

    AB - Literature reviews lay the foundation for almost every academic research project, and sometimes are a scholarly contribution in its own right. To increase rigor and credibility the findings have to be valid and reliable just as in any other type of research. This paper summarizes recent methodological developments in the application systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. It analyzes what approaches researchers in supply chain management have taken to follow the requirements of a systematic review, identifies issues in the approaches and provides authors, reviewers and editors with suggestions to better craft, disseminate, evaluate and select systematic literature reviews in supply chain management. This paper applies a systematic literature review approach to identify and analyze 31 articles published in core supply chain journals. It is the first research to map these developments, since three seminal methodology papers on systematic reviews in management research have been published between 2003-2009. This research shows that there is still a need for more transparency in the approaches taken. Systematic literature reviews have a high potential to advance the field, but a rigorous and transparent application is needed and should be requested by reviewers and editors.

    KW - Systematic literature review

    KW - Methodology

    KW - Supply chain management

    M3 - Paper

    ER -

    Durach CF, Wieland A, Kembro J. A Guide to the Systematic Literature Review Methodology in Supply Chain Management: Recommendations for Authors, Reviewers and Editors. 2014. Paper presented at The 9th European Research Seminar on Logistics and SCM. ERS 2014, Düsseldorf, Germany.