Abstract
This study investigates the effectiveness and relevance of valuation multiples, specifically the Price-toEarnings (P/E) and Price-to-Book (P/B) ratios, in predicting stock performance within the context of value investing. Focusing on data from the S&P 500 index between 1991 and 2022, the study analyses the performance of portfolios constructed based on Multiple Score, P/E and P/B ratios and examines the role of sector distribution. The research question addressed is: How effective and relevant are multiples in predicting stock performance in the context of value investing? The excess returns of the different portfolios are controlled against known risk factors by applying traditional asset pricing models, CAPM, Fama-French Three- and Five-Factor, the Momentum-Factor and Arbitrage Pricing Theory models, including macro factors and sector specific risk factors. Moreover, the sector distribution proved relevant, as the constructions revealed that the multiples in different industries vary dramatically. In the sector biased portfolios, several sector overweights were observed, for instance, Information Technology was overrepresented among companies with high valuation multiples. The sector neutral portfolios were constructed to counter these sector tilts, resulting in identical weightings across all four quartile portfolios. The research reveals significant abnormal returns in the quartile 1 portfolios of both sector neutral and sector biased portfolios. The initial scope of the study narrows to focus on the P/B ratios, as both quartiles 1 and 4 sector biased P/B portfolios yield positive significant abnormal returns and thereby contradict expectations from earlier literature. This outcome suggests that sector bias has an explanatory power. A possible explanation for the P/B ratios' ineffectiveness in modern times is the emergence of knowledgeintensive industries, where the book value may not effectively capture intangible assets' value. The study concludes that while multiples remain relevant as easy-to-use valuation metrics, the P/B ratio does not effectively function as a sector-wide indicator of value in an S&P 500 investment universe anymore. This conclusion necessitates the development of revised approaches to value investing using valuation multiples.
| Uddannelser | Cand.merc.fsm Finance and Strategic Management, (Kandidatuddannelse) Afsluttende afhandlingCand.merc.fin Finance and Investments, (Kandidatuddannelse) Afsluttende afhandling |
|---|---|
| Sprog | Engelsk |
| Udgivelsesdato | 15 maj 2023 |
| Antal sider | 130 |