The Role of Theory in Supply Chain Management: A Comprehensive Review

Dane Paul Pflueger, Andreas Wieland, Christopher Chapman

Publikation: Bidrag til bog/antologi/rapportKonferenceabstrakt i proceedingsForskningpeer review

Resumé

This paper contributes to contemporary debates over the apparent tradeoff between relevance and rigor in supply chain management (SCM) research. Building on Suddaby (2015), we advance the case for explicit and reflexive engagement with a diversity of paradigmatic choices and their alternatives as part of a healthy system of knowledge production. Based on an analysis of recent articles published across twelve SCM journals, we find a diversity and strength in research across a stylized dichotomy between modelling and empiricism, and between work adopting both quantitative and qualitative methods. Whilst there is great strength in all of these positivist endeavors however, our analysis illuminates a scarcity of work that treats theory as a normative tool for fashioning lenses that allow us to analyze the world as it might be. Drawing from examples of interpretive work from adjacent disciplines we elaborate the possibilities of this role of theory to complement the strength of the existing system of knowledge production. Specifically, it is argued that through its more explicit engagement with values, interpretive research can help to support the relevance of all SCM research. This is partly through the introduction of new forms of questions that arise from an interpretivist paradigm. Perhaps more importantly, however, greater paradigmatic pluralism would add to the reflexive capacity of the field also in relation to existing forms of questions addressed through positivistic work.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
TitelAcademy of Management Proceedings 2019
RedaktørerGuclu Atinc
Antal sider1
Udgivelses stedBriarcliff Manor, NY
ForlagAcademy of Management
Publikationsdato2019
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 2019
BegivenhedThe Academy of Management Annual Meeting 2019: Understanding the Inclusive Organization - Boston, USA
Varighed: 9 aug. 201913 aug. 2019
Konferencens nummer: 79
http://aom.org/annualmeeting/

Konference

KonferenceThe Academy of Management Annual Meeting 2019
Nummer79
LandUSA
ByBoston
Periode09/08/201913/08/2019
Internetadresse
NavnAcademy of Management Proceedings
ISSN2151-6561

Citer dette

Pflueger, D. P., Wieland, A., & Chapman, C. (2019). The Role of Theory in Supply Chain Management: A Comprehensive Review. I G. Atinc (red.), Academy of Management Proceedings 2019 Briarcliff Manor, NY: Academy of Management. Academy of Management Proceedings https://doi.org/10.5465/AMBPP.2019.15158abstract
Pflueger, Dane Paul ; Wieland, Andreas ; Chapman, Christopher . / The Role of Theory in Supply Chain Management: A Comprehensive Review. Academy of Management Proceedings 2019. red. / Guclu Atinc. Briarcliff Manor, NY : Academy of Management, 2019. (Academy of Management Proceedings).
@inbook{3971f2c956eb447b94a13566c95187ea,
title = "The Role of Theory in Supply Chain Management: A Comprehensive Review",
abstract = "This paper contributes to contemporary debates over the apparent tradeoff between relevance and rigor in supply chain management (SCM) research. Building on Suddaby (2015), we advance the case for explicit and reflexive engagement with a diversity of paradigmatic choices and their alternatives as part of a healthy system of knowledge production. Based on an analysis of recent articles published across twelve SCM journals, we find a diversity and strength in research across a stylized dichotomy between modelling and empiricism, and between work adopting both quantitative and qualitative methods. Whilst there is great strength in all of these positivist endeavors however, our analysis illuminates a scarcity of work that treats theory as a normative tool for fashioning lenses that allow us to analyze the world as it might be. Drawing from examples of interpretive work from adjacent disciplines we elaborate the possibilities of this role of theory to complement the strength of the existing system of knowledge production. Specifically, it is argued that through its more explicit engagement with values, interpretive research can help to support the relevance of all SCM research. This is partly through the introduction of new forms of questions that arise from an interpretivist paradigm. Perhaps more importantly, however, greater paradigmatic pluralism would add to the reflexive capacity of the field also in relation to existing forms of questions addressed through positivistic work.",
author = "Pflueger, {Dane Paul} and Andreas Wieland and Christopher Chapman",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.5465/AMBPP.2019.15158abstract",
language = "English",
series = "Academy of Management Proceedings",
editor = "Guclu Atinc",
booktitle = "Academy of Management Proceedings 2019",
publisher = "Academy of Management",

}

Pflueger, DP, Wieland, A & Chapman, C 2019, The Role of Theory in Supply Chain Management: A Comprehensive Review. i G Atinc (red.), Academy of Management Proceedings 2019. Academy of Management, Briarcliff Manor, NY, Academy of Management Proceedings, The Academy of Management Annual Meeting 2019, Boston, USA, 09/08/2019. https://doi.org/10.5465/AMBPP.2019.15158abstract

The Role of Theory in Supply Chain Management: A Comprehensive Review. / Pflueger, Dane Paul; Wieland, Andreas; Chapman, Christopher .

Academy of Management Proceedings 2019. red. / Guclu Atinc. Briarcliff Manor, NY : Academy of Management, 2019. (Academy of Management Proceedings).

Publikation: Bidrag til bog/antologi/rapportKonferenceabstrakt i proceedingsForskningpeer review

TY - ABST

T1 - The Role of Theory in Supply Chain Management: A Comprehensive Review

AU - Pflueger, Dane Paul

AU - Wieland, Andreas

AU - Chapman, Christopher

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - This paper contributes to contemporary debates over the apparent tradeoff between relevance and rigor in supply chain management (SCM) research. Building on Suddaby (2015), we advance the case for explicit and reflexive engagement with a diversity of paradigmatic choices and their alternatives as part of a healthy system of knowledge production. Based on an analysis of recent articles published across twelve SCM journals, we find a diversity and strength in research across a stylized dichotomy between modelling and empiricism, and between work adopting both quantitative and qualitative methods. Whilst there is great strength in all of these positivist endeavors however, our analysis illuminates a scarcity of work that treats theory as a normative tool for fashioning lenses that allow us to analyze the world as it might be. Drawing from examples of interpretive work from adjacent disciplines we elaborate the possibilities of this role of theory to complement the strength of the existing system of knowledge production. Specifically, it is argued that through its more explicit engagement with values, interpretive research can help to support the relevance of all SCM research. This is partly through the introduction of new forms of questions that arise from an interpretivist paradigm. Perhaps more importantly, however, greater paradigmatic pluralism would add to the reflexive capacity of the field also in relation to existing forms of questions addressed through positivistic work.

AB - This paper contributes to contemporary debates over the apparent tradeoff between relevance and rigor in supply chain management (SCM) research. Building on Suddaby (2015), we advance the case for explicit and reflexive engagement with a diversity of paradigmatic choices and their alternatives as part of a healthy system of knowledge production. Based on an analysis of recent articles published across twelve SCM journals, we find a diversity and strength in research across a stylized dichotomy between modelling and empiricism, and between work adopting both quantitative and qualitative methods. Whilst there is great strength in all of these positivist endeavors however, our analysis illuminates a scarcity of work that treats theory as a normative tool for fashioning lenses that allow us to analyze the world as it might be. Drawing from examples of interpretive work from adjacent disciplines we elaborate the possibilities of this role of theory to complement the strength of the existing system of knowledge production. Specifically, it is argued that through its more explicit engagement with values, interpretive research can help to support the relevance of all SCM research. This is partly through the introduction of new forms of questions that arise from an interpretivist paradigm. Perhaps more importantly, however, greater paradigmatic pluralism would add to the reflexive capacity of the field also in relation to existing forms of questions addressed through positivistic work.

U2 - 10.5465/AMBPP.2019.15158abstract

DO - 10.5465/AMBPP.2019.15158abstract

M3 - Conference abstract in proceedings

T3 - Academy of Management Proceedings

BT - Academy of Management Proceedings 2019

A2 - Atinc, Guclu

PB - Academy of Management

CY - Briarcliff Manor, NY

ER -

Pflueger DP, Wieland A, Chapman C. The Role of Theory in Supply Chain Management: A Comprehensive Review. I Atinc G, red., Academy of Management Proceedings 2019. Briarcliff Manor, NY: Academy of Management. 2019. (Academy of Management Proceedings). https://doi.org/10.5465/AMBPP.2019.15158abstract