The Management Academia: A Naked Carnival

    Publikation: Working paperForskning

    1 Downloads (Pure)

    Resumé

    This paper describes the current state of the management academia as a naked carnival, namely, most of the management researches have no such a clothes called practical relevance. It is intended to provide an explanation why management research has become irrelevant to the real management practice. It argues there are three factors behind the irrelevance problem: first, the ‘scientific model’ of management studies generates an initial and internal force which pushes the management research away from practice management studies supposed to serve; second, paradigm maintenance effort of the mainstream management scholars prevents the irrelevant management academia moving back towards management practice; third, the surrounding environment provides the management academia anything but a strong counter force to change the irrelevance reality. This paper also argues any solutions under the ‘scientific model’ are doomed to failure; and the only way out is to completely abandon the ‘scientific model’ and adopt a ‘professional model’ of management studies. Unfortunately, this paper argues such a radical change from within is highly unlikely to happen.
    OriginalsprogEngelsk
    Udgivelses stedFrederiksberg
    UdgiverDepartment of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School
    Antal sider27
    StatusUdgivet - 2009
    NavnWorking Paper / Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School
    Nummer1-2009

    Citer dette

    Li, X. (2009). The Management Academia: A Naked Carnival. Frederiksberg: Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School. Working Paper / Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School, Nr. 1-2009
    Li, Xin. / The Management Academia : A Naked Carnival. Frederiksberg : Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School, 2009. (Working Paper / Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School; Nr. 1-2009).
    @techreport{da941da4906f42ff84382d8e0d9ddd2c,
    title = "The Management Academia: A Naked Carnival",
    abstract = "This paper describes the current state of the management academia as a naked carnival, namely, most of the management researches have no such a clothes called practical relevance. It is intended to provide an explanation why management research has become irrelevant to the real management practice. It argues there are three factors behind the irrelevance problem: first, the ‘scientific model’ of management studies generates an initial and internal force which pushes the management research away from practice management studies supposed to serve; second, paradigm maintenance effort of the mainstream management scholars prevents the irrelevant management academia moving back towards management practice; third, the surrounding environment provides the management academia anything but a strong counter force to change the irrelevance reality. This paper also argues any solutions under the ‘scientific model’ are doomed to failure; and the only way out is to completely abandon the ‘scientific model’ and adopt a ‘professional model’ of management studies. Unfortunately, this paper argues such a radical change from within is highly unlikely to happen.",
    author = "Xin Li",
    year = "2009",
    language = "English",
    series = "Working Paper / Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School",
    publisher = "Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School",
    number = "1-2009",
    type = "WorkingPaper",
    institution = "Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School",

    }

    Li, X 2009 'The Management Academia: A Naked Carnival' Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School, Frederiksberg.

    The Management Academia : A Naked Carnival. / Li, Xin.

    Frederiksberg : Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School, 2009.

    Publikation: Working paperForskning

    TY - UNPB

    T1 - The Management Academia

    T2 - A Naked Carnival

    AU - Li, Xin

    PY - 2009

    Y1 - 2009

    N2 - This paper describes the current state of the management academia as a naked carnival, namely, most of the management researches have no such a clothes called practical relevance. It is intended to provide an explanation why management research has become irrelevant to the real management practice. It argues there are three factors behind the irrelevance problem: first, the ‘scientific model’ of management studies generates an initial and internal force which pushes the management research away from practice management studies supposed to serve; second, paradigm maintenance effort of the mainstream management scholars prevents the irrelevant management academia moving back towards management practice; third, the surrounding environment provides the management academia anything but a strong counter force to change the irrelevance reality. This paper also argues any solutions under the ‘scientific model’ are doomed to failure; and the only way out is to completely abandon the ‘scientific model’ and adopt a ‘professional model’ of management studies. Unfortunately, this paper argues such a radical change from within is highly unlikely to happen.

    AB - This paper describes the current state of the management academia as a naked carnival, namely, most of the management researches have no such a clothes called practical relevance. It is intended to provide an explanation why management research has become irrelevant to the real management practice. It argues there are three factors behind the irrelevance problem: first, the ‘scientific model’ of management studies generates an initial and internal force which pushes the management research away from practice management studies supposed to serve; second, paradigm maintenance effort of the mainstream management scholars prevents the irrelevant management academia moving back towards management practice; third, the surrounding environment provides the management academia anything but a strong counter force to change the irrelevance reality. This paper also argues any solutions under the ‘scientific model’ are doomed to failure; and the only way out is to completely abandon the ‘scientific model’ and adopt a ‘professional model’ of management studies. Unfortunately, this paper argues such a radical change from within is highly unlikely to happen.

    M3 - Working paper

    T3 - Working Paper / Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School

    BT - The Management Academia

    PB - Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School

    CY - Frederiksberg

    ER -

    Li X. The Management Academia: A Naked Carnival. Frederiksberg: Department of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School. 2009.