The Life Saving Effects of Hospital Proximity

Paola Bertoli, Veronica Grembi

Publikation: Working paperForskning

Resumé

We assess the lifesaving effect of hospital proximity using data on fatality rates of road-traffic accidents. While most of the literature on this topic is based on changes in distance to the nearest hospital triggered by hospital closures and use OLS estimates, our identification comes from the exogenous variation in the proximity to cities that are allowed by law to have a hospital based on their population size. Our instrumental variable results, based on Italian municipalities data from 2000 to 2012, show that an increase by a standard deviation of distance to the nearest hospital (5 km) increases the fatality rate by 13.84% on the sample average. This is equal to a 0.92 additional death per every 100 accidents. We show that OLS estimates provide a downward biased measure of the real effect of hospital proximity because they do not fully solve spatial sorting problems. Proximity matters more when the road safety is low; the emergency service is not properly organized, and the nearest hospital has lower quality standards.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
Udgivelses stedRome
UdgiverCEIS - Tor Vergata
Antal sider40
StatusUdgivet - jul. 2015
NavnResearch Paper Series / CEIS Tor Vergata
Nummer7 (no. 349)
Vol/bind13

Emneord

  • Access to care
  • Hospital proximity
  • Road-traffic accidents
  • Instrumental variables
  • Difference in differences

Citer dette

Bertoli, P., & Grembi, V. (2015). The Life Saving Effects of Hospital Proximity. Rome: CEIS - Tor Vergata. Research Paper Series / CEIS Tor Vergata, Nr. 7 (no. 349), Bind. 13
Bertoli, Paola ; Grembi, Veronica . / The Life Saving Effects of Hospital Proximity. Rome : CEIS - Tor Vergata, 2015. (Research Paper Series / CEIS Tor Vergata; Nr. 7 (no. 349), Bind 13).
@techreport{4aab1704c2a147c5bdede58978efcbaa,
title = "The Life Saving Effects of Hospital Proximity",
abstract = "We assess the lifesaving effect of hospital proximity using data on fatality rates of road-traffic accidents. While most of the literature on this topic is based on changes in distance to the nearest hospital triggered by hospital closures and use OLS estimates, our identification comes from the exogenous variation in the proximity to cities that are allowed by law to have a hospital based on their population size. Our instrumental variable results, based on Italian municipalities data from 2000 to 2012, show that an increase by a standard deviation of distance to the nearest hospital (5 km) increases the fatality rate by 13.84{\%} on the sample average. This is equal to a 0.92 additional death per every 100 accidents. We show that OLS estimates provide a downward biased measure of the real effect of hospital proximity because they do not fully solve spatial sorting problems. Proximity matters more when the road safety is low; the emergency service is not properly organized, and the nearest hospital has lower quality standards.",
keywords = "Access to care, Hospital proximity, Road-traffic accidents, Instrumental variables, Difference in differences, Access to care, Hospital proximity, Road-traffic accidents, Instrumental variables, Difference in differences",
author = "Paola Bertoli and Veronica Grembi",
year = "2015",
month = "7",
language = "English",
series = "Research Paper Series / CEIS Tor Vergata",
publisher = "CEIS - Tor Vergata",
number = "7 (no. 349)",
address = "Italy",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "CEIS - Tor Vergata",

}

Bertoli, P & Grembi, V 2015 'The Life Saving Effects of Hospital Proximity' CEIS - Tor Vergata, Rome.

The Life Saving Effects of Hospital Proximity. / Bertoli, Paola; Grembi, Veronica .

Rome : CEIS - Tor Vergata, 2015.

Publikation: Working paperForskning

TY - UNPB

T1 - The Life Saving Effects of Hospital Proximity

AU - Bertoli, Paola

AU - Grembi, Veronica

PY - 2015/7

Y1 - 2015/7

N2 - We assess the lifesaving effect of hospital proximity using data on fatality rates of road-traffic accidents. While most of the literature on this topic is based on changes in distance to the nearest hospital triggered by hospital closures and use OLS estimates, our identification comes from the exogenous variation in the proximity to cities that are allowed by law to have a hospital based on their population size. Our instrumental variable results, based on Italian municipalities data from 2000 to 2012, show that an increase by a standard deviation of distance to the nearest hospital (5 km) increases the fatality rate by 13.84% on the sample average. This is equal to a 0.92 additional death per every 100 accidents. We show that OLS estimates provide a downward biased measure of the real effect of hospital proximity because they do not fully solve spatial sorting problems. Proximity matters more when the road safety is low; the emergency service is not properly organized, and the nearest hospital has lower quality standards.

AB - We assess the lifesaving effect of hospital proximity using data on fatality rates of road-traffic accidents. While most of the literature on this topic is based on changes in distance to the nearest hospital triggered by hospital closures and use OLS estimates, our identification comes from the exogenous variation in the proximity to cities that are allowed by law to have a hospital based on their population size. Our instrumental variable results, based on Italian municipalities data from 2000 to 2012, show that an increase by a standard deviation of distance to the nearest hospital (5 km) increases the fatality rate by 13.84% on the sample average. This is equal to a 0.92 additional death per every 100 accidents. We show that OLS estimates provide a downward biased measure of the real effect of hospital proximity because they do not fully solve spatial sorting problems. Proximity matters more when the road safety is low; the emergency service is not properly organized, and the nearest hospital has lower quality standards.

KW - Access to care

KW - Hospital proximity

KW - Road-traffic accidents

KW - Instrumental variables

KW - Difference in differences

KW - Access to care

KW - Hospital proximity

KW - Road-traffic accidents

KW - Instrumental variables

KW - Difference in differences

M3 - Working paper

T3 - Research Paper Series / CEIS Tor Vergata

BT - The Life Saving Effects of Hospital Proximity

PB - CEIS - Tor Vergata

CY - Rome

ER -

Bertoli P, Grembi V. The Life Saving Effects of Hospital Proximity. Rome: CEIS - Tor Vergata. 2015 jul.