Spring til hovednavigation Spring til søgning Spring til hovedindhold

The Formation of the Interests: A Normative Conception of Motivation and its Implications for the Ends of Learning

  • Mads Kogut

Publikation: Bog/antologi/afhandling/rapport › Ph.d.-afhandling

87 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This dissertation critically examines conceptions of human motivation in post-Darwinian theories of learning from the beginning of the 20th century to present day. The critical examination concentrates on the influential works of John Dewey, Jerome Bruner, and Albert Bandura and the role they play in our understanding of ends in education. The overall aim is to develop an alternative, Kantian-inspired conception of motivation which allows for a better understanding of the role of ends in educational practices. The interests, as something publicly available that is (esse) between (inter-) us and not in a private relation to the environment, is used to pick out this alternative conception of motivation.
The first part of the dissertation, centered around the article “Learning for the sake of growth? – A Kantian recovery of our normative motivation to learn”, presents three argumentative steps. In a first step, I demonstrate how a common thread ties together learning theories across considerable variations. I argue that the common denominator of learning theory is the framing of learning as an interactional relation to the environment, where needs and particular environmental circumstances interact to produce opportunities and challenges that the individual must meet through learning. Accordingly, what calls for action and learning is given in an experience of interactional pressures, and the human capacity for rational thought, possessing no efficacy of its own, is set in motion by and at the behest of prior non-rational motivating pressures, referred to as ‘tensions’, ‘drives’, or ‘incentives’ depending on the theory. On this picture, rational thought greatly enhances human beings’ potential for learning, without transforming their basic motivational makeup.
The second step consists in showing that this theorization of human motivation and learning comes at the price of conceiving human motivation as an essentially private matter. By implication, because motivation – as the efficient cause of any actualization of ends through action – is depicted as private, privacy will extend to every determination of ends which can actually be realized. In learning theory and the educational measures it inspires, this price is paid by renouncing shared reflection on ends or through bewilderment of how to justify the inclusion of such reflection in education. The available justifications for education seem restricted to its instrumental value expressed as its capacity to create growth or foster success, while justifications invoking the cultivation of our capacity to evaluate the goodness of ends appear unavailable.
The third step delineates and argues for an alternative conception of human motivation (and learning) as an essentially shared or public matter. On this conception, which relies on recent philosophical elaborations of the Kantian account of motivation (Christine Korsgaard, Stephen Engstrom, Andrea Kern, and Stanley Cavell), human interests are irreducible to non-rational experiences of interactional pressures because their basic intelligibility and availability can only occur in the normative space of shared human meaning. While this does not imply that the interests in themselves contain any answers to the question of why something is worth caring about (justifications of goodness), they do imply learned criteria for the worth of something that we care about (criteria of goodness), which can be communicated, questioned and be subject to different forms of justification. On this account, instrumental value can only appear dissociated from the evaluation of the goodness of the interests we pursue and the objects they involve.
In the second part of the dissertation, I explore two possibilities for engaging with the formation of the interests in higher education, delineated in the articles ”Intellectual emancipation as minimal humanism – The relevance of Jacques Rancière in business school teaching” and ”The (lost) object of problematization analysis: A comprehensive review of a central notion in Michel Foucault’s later work (1975-1984)”. At the risk of sparking controversy, I interpret Jacques Rancière’s work on education and Michel Foucault’s late work on problematizations as participating in the aim of rendering the public nature of the interests intelligible to us. While both staunchly refuse to provide any guidance towards answering the question of why something is worth caring about (justifications of goodness), they both work from the assumption that learning and sharing criteria for the worth of what we care about is an irreducible part of human life.
In summary, the dissertation develops an account of human motivation hospitable to the educational purpose of cultivating our capacity evaluate ends. It thereby deviates from the contemporary drift of learning theory and draws attention to the possibility of another educational course.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
UdgivelsesstedFrederiksberg
ForlagCopenhagen Business School [Phd]
Antal sider199
ISBN (Trykt)9788775683796
ISBN (Elektronisk)9788775683802
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 2025
NavnPhD Series
Nummer30.2025
ISSN0906-6934

Citationsformater