Job Displacement and Crime

Evidence from Danish Microdata

Patrick Bennett, Amine Ouazad

Publikation: Working paperForskning

Resumé

This paper matches a comprehensive Danish employer-employee data set with individual crime information (timing of offenses, charges, convictions, and prison terms by crime type) to estimate the impact of job displacement on an individual’s propensity to commit crime. We focus on displaced individuals, i.e. high-tenure workers with strong attachment to their firm, who lose employment during a mass-layoff event. Pre-displacement data suggests no evidence of endogenous selection of workers for displacement during mass-layoffs: displaced workers’ propensity to commit crime exhibits no significantly increasing trend prior to displacement; and the crime rate of workers who will be displaced is not significantly higher than the crime rate of
workers who will not be displaced. In contrast, displaced workers’ probability to commit any crime increases by 0.52 percentage points in the year of job separation. The effects are driven by the propensity to commit property crime, which increases by 0.38 percentage points, or about 26% of the population-wide average. The substantial post-displacement earnings losses, coupled with the effects on property crime, are consistent with Becker’s (1968) economic theory of crime. Marital dissolution is more likely post-displacement, and we find small intra-family externalities of adult displacement on younger family members’ crime. The impact of displacement on crime is stronger in municipalities with higher capital and labor income inequalities.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
Udgivelses stedFontainebleau
UdgiverINSEAD
Antal sider70
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 2016
NavnINSEAD Working Paper
Nummer2016/55/EPS

Emneord

  • Job displacement
  • Crime
  • Labor economics
  • Unemployment
  • Earnings

Citer dette

Bennett, P., & Ouazad, A. (2016). Job Displacement and Crime: Evidence from Danish Microdata. Fontainebleau: INSEAD. INSEAD Working Paper, Nr. 2016/55/EPS https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2815312
Bennett, Patrick ; Ouazad, Amine. / Job Displacement and Crime : Evidence from Danish Microdata. Fontainebleau : INSEAD, 2016. (INSEAD Working Paper; Nr. 2016/55/EPS).
@techreport{fd88ead922cd43e99efca5b7420381be,
title = "Job Displacement and Crime: Evidence from Danish Microdata",
abstract = "This paper matches a comprehensive Danish employer-employee data set with individual crime information (timing of offenses, charges, convictions, and prison terms by crime type) to estimate the impact of job displacement on an individual’s propensity to commit crime. We focus on displaced individuals, i.e. high-tenure workers with strong attachment to their firm, who lose employment during a mass-layoff event. Pre-displacement data suggests no evidence of endogenous selection of workers for displacement during mass-layoffs: displaced workers’ propensity to commit crime exhibits no significantly increasing trend prior to displacement; and the crime rate of workers who will be displaced is not significantly higher than the crime rate ofworkers who will not be displaced. In contrast, displaced workers’ probability to commit any crime increases by 0.52 percentage points in the year of job separation. The effects are driven by the propensity to commit property crime, which increases by 0.38 percentage points, or about 26{\%} of the population-wide average. The substantial post-displacement earnings losses, coupled with the effects on property crime, are consistent with Becker’s (1968) economic theory of crime. Marital dissolution is more likely post-displacement, and we find small intra-family externalities of adult displacement on younger family members’ crime. The impact of displacement on crime is stronger in municipalities with higher capital and labor income inequalities.",
keywords = "Job displacement, Crime, Labor economics, Unemployment, Earnings, Job displacement, Crime, Labor economics, Unemployment, Earnings",
author = "Patrick Bennett and Amine Ouazad",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.2139/ssrn.2815312",
language = "English",
publisher = "INSEAD",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "INSEAD",

}

Job Displacement and Crime : Evidence from Danish Microdata. / Bennett, Patrick; Ouazad, Amine.

Fontainebleau : INSEAD, 2016.

Publikation: Working paperForskning

TY - UNPB

T1 - Job Displacement and Crime

T2 - Evidence from Danish Microdata

AU - Bennett, Patrick

AU - Ouazad, Amine

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - This paper matches a comprehensive Danish employer-employee data set with individual crime information (timing of offenses, charges, convictions, and prison terms by crime type) to estimate the impact of job displacement on an individual’s propensity to commit crime. We focus on displaced individuals, i.e. high-tenure workers with strong attachment to their firm, who lose employment during a mass-layoff event. Pre-displacement data suggests no evidence of endogenous selection of workers for displacement during mass-layoffs: displaced workers’ propensity to commit crime exhibits no significantly increasing trend prior to displacement; and the crime rate of workers who will be displaced is not significantly higher than the crime rate ofworkers who will not be displaced. In contrast, displaced workers’ probability to commit any crime increases by 0.52 percentage points in the year of job separation. The effects are driven by the propensity to commit property crime, which increases by 0.38 percentage points, or about 26% of the population-wide average. The substantial post-displacement earnings losses, coupled with the effects on property crime, are consistent with Becker’s (1968) economic theory of crime. Marital dissolution is more likely post-displacement, and we find small intra-family externalities of adult displacement on younger family members’ crime. The impact of displacement on crime is stronger in municipalities with higher capital and labor income inequalities.

AB - This paper matches a comprehensive Danish employer-employee data set with individual crime information (timing of offenses, charges, convictions, and prison terms by crime type) to estimate the impact of job displacement on an individual’s propensity to commit crime. We focus on displaced individuals, i.e. high-tenure workers with strong attachment to their firm, who lose employment during a mass-layoff event. Pre-displacement data suggests no evidence of endogenous selection of workers for displacement during mass-layoffs: displaced workers’ propensity to commit crime exhibits no significantly increasing trend prior to displacement; and the crime rate of workers who will be displaced is not significantly higher than the crime rate ofworkers who will not be displaced. In contrast, displaced workers’ probability to commit any crime increases by 0.52 percentage points in the year of job separation. The effects are driven by the propensity to commit property crime, which increases by 0.38 percentage points, or about 26% of the population-wide average. The substantial post-displacement earnings losses, coupled with the effects on property crime, are consistent with Becker’s (1968) economic theory of crime. Marital dissolution is more likely post-displacement, and we find small intra-family externalities of adult displacement on younger family members’ crime. The impact of displacement on crime is stronger in municipalities with higher capital and labor income inequalities.

KW - Job displacement

KW - Crime

KW - Labor economics

KW - Unemployment

KW - Earnings

KW - Job displacement

KW - Crime

KW - Labor economics

KW - Unemployment

KW - Earnings

U2 - 10.2139/ssrn.2815312

DO - 10.2139/ssrn.2815312

M3 - Working paper

BT - Job Displacement and Crime

PB - INSEAD

CY - Fontainebleau

ER -