Jane Addams’s Pragmatist Method Extended: Care Work Between Abstract Rules and Situated Practice

    Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

    8 Downloads (Pure)


    Although Jane Addams has long been recognized as a pioneer in North American pragmatism, efforts to develop her thought into a distinct research program have been limited. This article develops Addams’s work as a method of sociological inquiry by focusing on her notions of “perplexity,” “moral adjustment,” and “sympathetic understanding.” Emphasizing the essential role of language in moral conflicts and reconstruction, the article incorporates Charles Wright Mills’s concept of “vocabularies of motives.” Together, these notions offer a framework for exploring the moral dilemmas that care workers experience when responding to the imposition of standardization of their working practices. A case study demonstrates how care workers, while coping creatively with the effects of a service reform, develop motive vocabularies in defense of their professional ethics. Such situated creativity on “the shop floor” of social services remains relatively under-explored and under-theorized.
    TidsskriftQualitative Inquiry
    Udgave nummer10
    Sider (fra-til)1027-1038
    Antal sider12
    StatusUdgivet - dec. 2022

    Bibliografisk note

    Published online: 06 June 2022.


    • Jane Addams
    • Pragmatist theory
    • Vocabularies of motives
    • Care ethics
    • Home care