Dimensions of Real-World Competition: A Critical Realist Perspective

    Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

    Resumé

    Mainstream economics consistently ignores the various socio-economic and environmental downsides of capitalist competition and instead lends legitimacy to the prevailing neoliberal discourse according to which merciless competition is unambiguously positive. In opposition to this one-dimensional view, the present paper delineates a heterodox perspective on competition that is able to recognise its many heterogeneous effects. The argument draws on selected aspects of the ontology of critical realism, adding substance to them with empirical findings and theoretical insights from different academic disciplines, with a particular focus on historical materialist political economy. Competition is conceptualised as a social relation, and the paper outlines how competition interacts with numerous other mechanisms to produce a variety of outcomes. Specifically, Roy Bhaskar’s concept of the social cube is utilised to propose a four-dimensional perspective that views competition in relation to (other) social relations, social practices, the subjectivity of agents and the natural environment.
    Mainstream economics consistently ignores the various socio-economic and environmental downsides of capitalist competition and instead lends legitimacy to the prevailing neoliberal discourse according to which merciless competition is unambiguously positive. In opposition to this one-dimensional view, the present paper delineates a heterodox perspective on competition that is able to recognise its many heterogeneous effects. The argument draws on selected aspects of the ontology of critical realism, adding substance to them with empirical findings and theoretical insights from different academic disciplines, with a particular focus on historical materialist political economy. Competition is conceptualised as a social relation, and the paper outlines how competition interacts with numerous other mechanisms to produce a variety of outcomes. Specifically, Roy Bhaskar’s concept of the social cube is utilised to propose a four-dimensional perspective that views competition in relation to (other) social relations, social practices, the subjectivity of agents and the natural environment.
    SprogEngelsk
    TidsskriftPost-Autistic Economic Review
    Vol/bind2014
    Udgave nummer66
    Sider80-94
    ISSN1755-9472
    StatusUdgivet - 13 jan. 2014

    Emneord

    • Competition
    • Critical realism
    • Social structures
    • The social cube

    Citer dette

    @article{8dbce37399b84d45933f3650832b4409,
    title = "Dimensions of Real-World Competition: A Critical Realist Perspective",
    abstract = "Mainstream economics consistently ignores the various socio-economic and environmental downsides of capitalist competition and instead lends legitimacy to the prevailing neoliberal discourse according to which merciless competition is unambiguously positive. In opposition to this one-dimensional view, the present paper delineates a heterodox perspective on competition that is able to recognise its many heterogeneous effects. The argument draws on selected aspects of the ontology of critical realism, adding substance to them with empirical findings and theoretical insights from different academic disciplines, with a particular focus on historical materialist political economy. Competition is conceptualised as a social relation, and the paper outlines how competition interacts with numerous other mechanisms to produce a variety of outcomes. Specifically, Roy Bhaskar’s concept of the social cube is utilised to propose a four-dimensional perspective that views competition in relation to (other) social relations, social practices, the subjectivity of agents and the natural environment.",
    keywords = "Competition, Critical realism, Social structures, The social cube, Competition, Critical realism, Social structures, The social cube",
    author = "Hubert Buch-Hansen",
    year = "2014",
    month = "1",
    day = "13",
    language = "English",
    volume = "2014",
    pages = "80--94",
    journal = "Post-Autistic Economic Review",
    issn = "1755-9472",
    publisher = "P A E News",
    number = "66",

    }

    Dimensions of Real-World Competition : A Critical Realist Perspective. / Buch-Hansen, Hubert.

    I: Post-Autistic Economic Review, Bind 2014, Nr. 66, 13.01.2014, s. 80-94.

    Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Dimensions of Real-World Competition

    T2 - Post-Autistic Economic Review

    AU - Buch-Hansen,Hubert

    PY - 2014/1/13

    Y1 - 2014/1/13

    N2 - Mainstream economics consistently ignores the various socio-economic and environmental downsides of capitalist competition and instead lends legitimacy to the prevailing neoliberal discourse according to which merciless competition is unambiguously positive. In opposition to this one-dimensional view, the present paper delineates a heterodox perspective on competition that is able to recognise its many heterogeneous effects. The argument draws on selected aspects of the ontology of critical realism, adding substance to them with empirical findings and theoretical insights from different academic disciplines, with a particular focus on historical materialist political economy. Competition is conceptualised as a social relation, and the paper outlines how competition interacts with numerous other mechanisms to produce a variety of outcomes. Specifically, Roy Bhaskar’s concept of the social cube is utilised to propose a four-dimensional perspective that views competition in relation to (other) social relations, social practices, the subjectivity of agents and the natural environment.

    AB - Mainstream economics consistently ignores the various socio-economic and environmental downsides of capitalist competition and instead lends legitimacy to the prevailing neoliberal discourse according to which merciless competition is unambiguously positive. In opposition to this one-dimensional view, the present paper delineates a heterodox perspective on competition that is able to recognise its many heterogeneous effects. The argument draws on selected aspects of the ontology of critical realism, adding substance to them with empirical findings and theoretical insights from different academic disciplines, with a particular focus on historical materialist political economy. Competition is conceptualised as a social relation, and the paper outlines how competition interacts with numerous other mechanisms to produce a variety of outcomes. Specifically, Roy Bhaskar’s concept of the social cube is utilised to propose a four-dimensional perspective that views competition in relation to (other) social relations, social practices, the subjectivity of agents and the natural environment.

    KW - Competition

    KW - Critical realism

    KW - Social structures

    KW - The social cube

    KW - Competition

    KW - Critical realism

    KW - Social structures

    KW - The social cube

    M3 - Journal article

    VL - 2014

    SP - 80

    EP - 94

    JO - Post-Autistic Economic Review

    JF - Post-Autistic Economic Review

    SN - 1755-9472

    IS - 66

    ER -