Conditions for Critical Performativity in a Polycontextural Society

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

38 Downloads (Pure)

Resumé

This paper argues that practice, not science, decides the performativity of science. The argument is inspired by Austin’s question of what it is that gives language its performative force. What are the conditions which connect sentences to certain effects? Advancing this question from the level of sentences to a societal level, and taking inspiration from the failure of Marxist notions of the relation between theory and practice, the paper suggests thinking critical performativity under the conditions of differentiation. This idea is qualified by means of Niklas Luhmann and his theory of a functionally differentiated – or polycontextural - society. Functional differentiation and polycontexturality mean that systems cannot communicate with each other; there is no real transfer of scientific knowledge into practice. Unhappy performativity is the rule. Based on this insight the paper discusses elements of a critical research strategy – under polycontextural conditions - and four guidelines for a critical science are suggested.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
TidsskriftM@n@gement
Vol/bind20
Udgave nummer1
Sider (fra-til)9-27
Antal sider19
ISSN1286-4692
StatusUdgivet - 2017

Emneord

  • Critical management studies
  • Critical performativity
  • Critical theory
  • Theory and practice
  • Luhmann
  • Systems theory
  • Functional
  • Polycontexturality
  • Polycontextural society
  • Science

Citer dette

@article{c2846b7f8ff84ba59dbb5c524245c40a,
title = "Conditions for Critical Performativity in a Polycontextural Society",
abstract = "This paper argues that practice, not science, decides the performativity of science. The argument is inspired by Austin’s question of what it is that gives language its performative force. What are the conditions which connect sentences to certain effects? Advancing this question from the level of sentences to a societal level, and taking inspiration from the failure of Marxist notions of the relation between theory and practice, the paper suggests thinking critical performativity under the conditions of differentiation. This idea is qualified by means of Niklas Luhmann and his theory of a functionally differentiated – or polycontextural - society. Functional differentiation and polycontexturality mean that systems cannot communicate with each other; there is no real transfer of scientific knowledge into practice. Unhappy performativity is the rule. Based on this insight the paper discusses elements of a critical research strategy – under polycontextural conditions - and four guidelines for a critical science are suggested.",
keywords = "Critical management studies, Critical performativity, Critical theory, Theory and practice, Luhmann, Systems theory, Functional, Polycontexturality, Polycontextural society, Science, Critical management studies, Critical performativity, Critical theory, Theory and practice, Luhmann, Systems theory, Functional, Polycontexturality, Polycontextural society, Science",
author = "Morten Knudsen",
year = "2017",
language = "English",
volume = "20",
pages = "9--27",
journal = "M@n@gement",
issn = "1286-4692",
publisher = "Association Internationale de Management Strategique (AIMS)",
number = "1",

}

Conditions for Critical Performativity in a Polycontextural Society. / Knudsen, Morten.

I: M@n@gement, Bind 20, Nr. 1, 2017, s. 9-27.

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Conditions for Critical Performativity in a Polycontextural Society

AU - Knudsen, Morten

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - This paper argues that practice, not science, decides the performativity of science. The argument is inspired by Austin’s question of what it is that gives language its performative force. What are the conditions which connect sentences to certain effects? Advancing this question from the level of sentences to a societal level, and taking inspiration from the failure of Marxist notions of the relation between theory and practice, the paper suggests thinking critical performativity under the conditions of differentiation. This idea is qualified by means of Niklas Luhmann and his theory of a functionally differentiated – or polycontextural - society. Functional differentiation and polycontexturality mean that systems cannot communicate with each other; there is no real transfer of scientific knowledge into practice. Unhappy performativity is the rule. Based on this insight the paper discusses elements of a critical research strategy – under polycontextural conditions - and four guidelines for a critical science are suggested.

AB - This paper argues that practice, not science, decides the performativity of science. The argument is inspired by Austin’s question of what it is that gives language its performative force. What are the conditions which connect sentences to certain effects? Advancing this question from the level of sentences to a societal level, and taking inspiration from the failure of Marxist notions of the relation between theory and practice, the paper suggests thinking critical performativity under the conditions of differentiation. This idea is qualified by means of Niklas Luhmann and his theory of a functionally differentiated – or polycontextural - society. Functional differentiation and polycontexturality mean that systems cannot communicate with each other; there is no real transfer of scientific knowledge into practice. Unhappy performativity is the rule. Based on this insight the paper discusses elements of a critical research strategy – under polycontextural conditions - and four guidelines for a critical science are suggested.

KW - Critical management studies

KW - Critical performativity

KW - Critical theory

KW - Theory and practice

KW - Luhmann

KW - Systems theory

KW - Functional

KW - Polycontexturality

KW - Polycontextural society

KW - Science

KW - Critical management studies

KW - Critical performativity

KW - Critical theory

KW - Theory and practice

KW - Luhmann

KW - Systems theory

KW - Functional

KW - Polycontexturality

KW - Polycontextural society

KW - Science

M3 - Journal article

VL - 20

SP - 9

EP - 27

JO - M@n@gement

JF - M@n@gement

SN - 1286-4692

IS - 1

ER -